Climate
ESG Narratives and the Talk–Walk Gap: Why Climate Commitments Still Fall Short
As ESG rhetoric becomes increasingly sophisticated, measurable climate outcomes continue to lag behind corporate promises. From net-zero pledges to digital green narratives, the growing “Talk–Walk Gap” raises urgent questions about accountability, transparency, and the future credibility of global sustainability commitments.
The end of 2025 marks the close of another chapter in which much of the global discourse appears to have grown comfortable with ESG (Environmental Social Governance) messaging, even as its tangible impact remains uncertain. What was once framed as a pathway toward an eco-friendly and socially responsible future increasingly risks stagnating as an idealistic, almost utopian concept.
Corporations, meanwhile, have become adept at constructing environments where ESG strategies are articulated confidently but seldom questioned. Sustainability reports are published, climate targets are announced, and long-term commitments are projected — yet the link between these narratives and measurable environmental outcomes often remains unclear.
As debates around ESG continue to unfold in the background, it becomes crucial to ask a more fundamental question: does corporate ESG practice genuinely seek to serve society in a holistic sense, or does it primarily operate to protect vested interests? Examining ESG narratives and their real-world implications is therefore essential, particularly given the immediacy and evolving nature of today’s climate and sustainability challenges.
Current Relevance and Importance
The relevance of this discussion intensifies amid the ongoing COP30 controversy, where the participation of major contributors to environmental instability has drawn global attention. Many of the actors shaping climate discourse continue to represent high-emission industries, raising concerns about how environmental threats are increasingly reframed as economic opportunities.
Factual investigations by Climate Action Against Disinformation (CAAD) offer a close-range view of how digital platforms were leveraged in the run-up to the summit. Their recent report documents how major oil companies made extensive use of Google’s advertising ecosystem, pursuing an aggressive strategy to influence online climate narratives. As of October 2025, oil company advertisements increased globally by 218%, while ads specifically targeting Brazil surged by 2,900%.
Company-level data further illustrates the scale of this intervention. Advertising activity by Saudi Aramco rose by 469.2% month-on-month in October, alongside significant increases by TotalEnergies (106.5%) and ExxonMobil (156.3%). Together, these patterns highlight the extent to which corporate actors can shape climate discourse during moments of heightened political attention (CAAD).
Parallel concerns were reflected in the Statement of Commitment on Climate Information Integrity in Digital Advertising, launched at COP30, which drew attention to climate-related advertising that disseminates misleading narratives, erodes public trust, and operates with limited transparency. The issue of climate disinformation is no longer abstract; it is observable, measurable, and increasingly consequential for public understanding and democratic accountability.
COP30, as a global stage for climate action, therefore also exposed the limits of information transparency in digital ecosystems. The prevalence of paid green narratives and strategic messaging raises questions about whose interests are amplified and whose are marginalised. In such settings, sustainability narratives function less as instruments of accountability and more as strategic proclamations designed to preserve influence and legitimacy, widening the distance between climate ambition and climate action.
Net Zero Commitments vs Net Zero Outcomes
Data from the Net Zero Tracker — a joint initiative of the Energy & Climate Intelligence Unit (ECIU), Data-Driven EnviroLab, the NewClimate Institute, and the University of Oxford — illustrates this imbalance clearly. The analysis indicates that 62.7% of companies actively communicate net-zero intentions through strategy, pledges, or proposed targets, yet fail to provide verifiable evidence of achievement. In contrast, only a negligible fraction of firms can demonstrate externally validated net-zero outcomes, based on an assessment of the world’s 2,000 largest publicly listed companies by annual revenue (Net Zero Tracker, 2024–2025 dataset).
This disparity suggests that ESG communication, in many cases, operates as a narrative exercise rather than a performance-driven framework. The widening gap between declared intent and measurable delivery makes it imperative to examine what can be described as the “Talk–Walk Gap” — the divergence between sustainability messaging and substantive environmental action.
Combining Next-Generation AI and ESG Accountability
Artificial Intelligence, particularly Natural Language Processing (NLP), offers a practical mechanism for analysing this gap. Repetition across CSR reports, sustainability disclosures, and corporate press releases can be systematically examined to identify patterns of narrative reuse rather than strategic progression.
Through techniques that assess verbal mimicry, keyword recurrence, and semantic similarity, NLP can help distinguish genuine ESG evolution from recycled sustainability rhetoric. When ESG language remains largely unchanged across reporting cycles, despite shifting climate risks and regulatory expectations, it raises questions about whether commitments are being operationalised or merely reiterated.
Such analytical tools allow consumers, investors, and policymakers to make more informed decisions. Importantly, they reduce the likelihood that green financing instruments and green bonds are used merely as tools of financial leverage rather than vehicles for genuine environmental transition. In this sense, AI does not replace accountability; it strengthens transparency by exposing inconsistencies between communication and action.
Aftermath
The implications of weak ESG accountability extend beyond corporate strategy and into everyday life. Sustainability narratives increasingly shape consumption patterns, influencing how products and technologies are marketed and normalised within ordinary lifestyles. From energy-intensive appliances to digitally driven conveniences, ESG claims often accompany commodities whose environmental alignment remains unclear.

Whether such practices genuinely contribute to global sustainability objectives — including UN Sustainable Development Goals 7 (Affordable and Clean Energy) and 12 (Responsible Consumption and Production) — remains uncertain within the current corporate landscape. Society itself becomes an unwitting participant in this system, reinforcing narratives without adequate mechanisms for verification.
In an era increasingly shaped by generative AI, the need to detect misalignment between corporate objectives, policy commitments, and actual performance becomes more pressing. While these technologies can be used to amplify corporate messaging, they can also be deployed in the public interest — as tools to flag inconsistencies, assess credibility, and strengthen accountability across ESG ecosystems.
The integration of AI into ESG governance is not without risk, and it requires clear ethical boundaries, institutional oversight, and internationally aligned standards. Frameworks developed by internal governance bodies, alongside external institutions such as the United Nations, can help ensure that AI serves as a mechanism for transparency rather than a vehicle for strategic distortion.
This underscores the growing importance of collective scrutiny and informed engagement with ESG principles. Understanding how sustainability is communicated, validated, and implemented is not merely a corporate concern, but a societal one. Addressing the Talk–Walk Gap therefore requires sustained evaluation, improved verification, and transparent progress — not abrupt disruption, but deliberate and accountable change.
Climate
Why Humid Heat Is Becoming India’s Most Dangerous Climate Threat
From menopausal women and taxi drivers to surfing instructors, rising humidity is making heat harder to escape—even indoors.
Humid Heat in India is emerging as a growing public health threat. Through data, expert insights and lived experiences from across the country, EdPublica explores how rising heat and humidity are making everyday life increasingly difficult for millions of Indians.
By 9 a.m., Radha, a 55-year-old office worker from Kottayam in the southern Indian state of Kerala, is already drenched in sweat as she waits for her bus. By noon, waves of heat, anxiety and discomfort begin to set in. Menopause had already brought frequent hot flashes, she says, but rising temperatures and humidity have made them harder to endure.
For Radha, relief no longer comes easily. Even routine tasks feel more exhausting than they once did. Her experience reflects a growing reality across India and much of the world: climate change is not only making the planet hotter, it is making heat harder for the human body to bear.
Humid Heat in India Taking a Growing Toll
When high temperatures combine with high humidity, the body struggles to cool itself through sweating, its primary cooling mechanism. As moisture in the air increases, sweat evaporates less efficiently, causing heat to build up inside the body.
A recent analysis by Climate Central found that dangerous humid heat days have more than doubled globally since the 1970s. The average number of dangerous humid heat days has risen from around 10 days per year to 23 days annually.
Alarmingly, climate change is now responsible for nearly two-thirds of these dangerous humid heat days. The consequences are increasingly visible. A study examining mortality linked to extreme heat events since 2000 estimates that more than 260,000 people have died from heat-related hazards worldwide.
Globally, climate change is now responsible for six times as many dangerous humid heat days each year as it was in the 1970s, underscoring how rapidly the risk has intensified. In 2025 alone, the world experienced an average of 23 dangerous humid heat days. Climate Central estimates that 19 of those days, or 83 percent, were added by human-caused climate change.
“These findings show how profoundly climate change is reshaping our world,” said Kaitlyn Trudeau, Applied Climate Scientist at Climate Central. “Dangerous humid heat has gone from being an uncommon event to a defining feature of daily life in some regions, pushing conditions closer to the limits of what the human body can safely endure.” Climate Central’s analysis of 961 cities worldwide found that 69 percent, or 665 cities, are now experiencing significantly more dangerous humid heat days because of climate change. On average, these cities recorded 46 additional dangerous humid heat days each year during the last decade compared with a world without human-caused warming.
Researchers say the findings highlight how climate change is evolving from an environmental concern into a growing public health emergency, particularly in regions already struggling with heat exposure, limited access to cooling and inadequate health infrastructure.
What Is Humid Heat?
Scientists often use “wet-bulb temperature” to measure humid heat. The metric combines air temperature and humidity to estimate how effectively the human body can cool itself through sweating.
Climate Central defines wet-bulb temperatures of 25°C or higher as dangerous humid heat conditions. When humidity and temperature combine to push wet-bulb temperatures upward, the body’s natural cooling system becomes less effective.
In extreme conditions, the body can no longer regulate its temperature adequately, increasing the risk of heat exhaustion, heat stroke and even death.
Older adults, children, pregnant women and people with pre-existing health conditions face the greatest risks. High humidity can worsen cardiovascular stress, respiratory illnesses and other heat-related health complications.
“Dangerous humid heat has more than doubled since the 1970s. We’re already seeing the consequences play out in real time,” said Lisa Patel, Clinical Associate Professor of Pediatrics at Stanford Children’s Health and Executive Director of the Medical Society Consortium on Climate and Health.
“As a pediatrician, these numbers are a wake-up call. This kind of data is exactly the tool clinicians and public health officials need to anticipate where heat-related illness will strike and who is most at risk before people end up in the emergency room.”
How Humid Heat Is Affecting India
Humid Heat in India is already becoming visible in several cities, particularly along the country’s southern and eastern coasts.
According to Climate Central’s analysis, Tamil Nadu emerges as India’s most affected state. Tirunelveli experiences an average of 273 dangerous humid heat days annually, the highest among Indian cities. Chennai follows with 257 days, while Tiruchirappalli records 251. Vijayawada and Visakhapatnam in Andhra Pradesh, along with Kolkata and Mumbai, are also among India’s humid-heat hotspots.
The danger does not end when people move indoors.
A separate study by Climate Trends found that heat exposure frequently continues inside homes. Researchers monitored temperatures and humidity in 50 low- and middle-income households in Chennai between October 2025 and April 2026 and found that indoor temperatures regularly exceeded 32°C.
Some households experienced more than 5,700 hours above this threshold—equivalent to nearly eight months of continuous heat exposure. Most households recorded between 3,000 and 5,000 hours of such conditions.
The findings suggest that for many urban residents, especially those without access to air conditioning, relief from heat remains elusive even indoors.
Heat, Menopause and Everyday Life
For women such as Radha, humid heat can intensify already challenging health conditions.
The World Health Organization notes that hot flushes and night sweats are among the most common symptoms associated with menopause. These episodes involve sudden sensations of heat in the face, neck and chest, often accompanied by sweating, flushing, palpitations and discomfort.
Women who have undergone hysterectomy are known to experience more frequent and severe hot flushes. According to NFHS-5 data, nearly one in ten women aged 30 to 49 in some regions of India have undergone the procedure.
As temperatures and humidity rise, these symptoms can become even more difficult to manage, adding another layer to the health impacts of climate change that often goes overlooked.
A City Struggling to Cool Down
In Mumbai, 59-year-old driver Vikas says heat has become one of the city’s biggest challenges.
Water shortages are becoming more common, and even routine outdoor work is growing increasingly difficult.
“Sometimes people go to the beach at night just to find some relief from the heat. Even a brief spell of rain feels like a blessing now,” he says. “The problem is only going to get worse.”

His observations echo broader climate trends in the Mumbai Metropolitan Region. Climate Central’s analysis shows that Mumbai experiences an average of 206 dangerous humid heat days annually, while nearby Dombivli and Thane record even higher numbers. The conditions he describes are reflected in current forecasts. Climate Central projected a daily high wet-bulb temperature of 25.6°C in Mumbai on June 23, a level considered dangerous humid heat.
Surfing Through a Hotter Coastline
Further south, the effects are also being felt along India’s coast.
Rajaguru, a surfing instructor in Puducherry, says summers are arriving earlier than before, often beginning in February instead of March.
“We go surfing early in the morning, but even then the heat feels much more intense than it used to,” he says. “Sunburns and skin rashes are becoming common. Summer arrives with extreme heat, while the monsoon season increasingly brings cyclones.”
He has also noticed rising sea temperatures and changes in water conditions that affect both tourism and outdoor activities.
For people whose livelihoods depend on spending long hours outdoors, humid heat is becoming more than an inconvenience—it is becoming an occupational hazard.
The Vulnerability Gap
These experiences reflect a larger challenge facing India. The impacts of Humid Heat in India are magnified by inequalities in access to cooling, housing and reliable electricity.
Between 1995 and 2024, the country experienced 430 extreme weather events, resulting in more than 80,000 deaths and economic losses exceeding USD 170 billion. Rapid urbanisation has intensified the urban heat island effect, making cities significantly hotter than surrounding rural areas.
The latest Climate Change in the Indian Mind survey found that 84 percent of Indians report experiencing the effects of global warming. Yet only 15 percent of households own an air conditioner and 27 percent have access to an air cooler.
Even for those with cooling systems, reliable electricity is not guaranteed. Around 66 percent of Indians experience power disruptions on a typical day, even as demand surges during heatwaves. On May 21, 2026, India’s peak electricity consumption reached a record 270 gigawatts.
Despite being the world’s third-largest emitter of carbon dioxide, India’s per-capita emissions remain relatively low, reflecting deep inequalities in energy consumption and access.
For millions of people, escaping extreme heat is simply not an option.
When the Air Stops Offering Relief
Dangerous Humid Heat in India is already reshaping how people live, work and survive. As temperatures and humidity continue to rise, the boundary between uncomfortable and life-threatening conditions is becoming increasingly thin.
For millions of Indians, the challenge is no longer adapting to hotter days. It is adapting to air that no longer offers relief. As humidity rises alongside temperatures, surviving heat may become as much about access to cooling and electricity as it is about climate itself.
The future of climate adaptation may begin not in policy documents or air-conditioned offices, but in homes, buses, streets and workplaces where the heat is already impossible to ignore.
Climate
India Wants Climate Action, Not Just Climate Warnings
Indians are calling for urgent climate action as pollution intensify. A new survey shows strong public support for clean energy and policy change.
Pollution in India has embedded itself into everyday life. The extent to which it affects people often goes unnoticed until it rides along with morning traffic, seeps through open windows, and settles into daily routines. Cities like Delhi and Ghaziabad routinely appear in global pollution rankings. The problem is structural, persistent, and increasingly demand climate action.
A recent survey on public perceptions of environmental issues suggests that Indians view climate change as an immediate threat to their local communities and personal well-being.
Widespread Concern Over Pollution
The survey highlighted a high level of anxiety regarding pollution in India. Around 77% of Indians expressed significant concern about air pollution. This concern exists alongside fears of other climate-related hazards, including severe heat waves (77%) and droughts or water shortages (76%). The findings suggest that the public views pollution as part of a broader environmental crisis already affecting everyday life.
“People need credible information about what governments, businesses, communities, and households can do, how clean-energy transitions create jobs and improve air quality, and how local actions connect to larger climate goals,” Jagadish Thaker, one of the lead authors of the study, told EdPublica.
Public concern over air quality is also reflected in environmental data. India ranked sixth among 143 countries in PM2.5 pollution levels in the 2025 World Air Quality Report. At the city level, the situation appears even more severe, with New Delhi continuing to rank as the world’s most polluted capital city for the eighth consecutive year.
Identifying the Culprits: Fossil Fuels and Coal
“What is striking in our data is how consistently supportive Indians are of the energy transition. These findings suggest that public opinion may be less of a barrier to climate and energy policy than is often assumed. For communicators, one challenge is helping people understand how long-term energy transitions actually occur and what role citizens can play in them,” said Thaker.

Large majorities of respondents identified oil (76%) and coal (68%) as polluting sources of electricity. India’s energy sector still relies on coal for nearly 70% of its electricity generation. At the same time, there is growing public recognition that coal is a major contributor to both local air pollution and global warming.
Interestingly, around 82% of Indians support banning the construction of new coal-fired power plants and gradually shutting down existing ones in favour of solar and wind energy. This support is driven by the belief that such a transition would benefit the people of India (87%) and offer the best pathway toward a “healthy, safe, and prosperous future.”
Shift Toward Climate Action
Support for renewable energy transitions is particularly strong. Nearly 95% of respondents favoured a national programme prioritising renewable-energy job training for youth and women, while 93% supported renewable-energy job training in general.
At the same time, 78% of Indians believe the government should be doing more to address climate and pollution-related challenges. Respondents also pointed to the need for hyperlocal, area-specific training programmes and structural policy reforms.
Reflecting on the findings, Thaker said: “These findings suggest that climate communication should not focus only on risks. Indians appear highly interested in solutions, skills, and opportunities. Effective climate education can help people understand climate change, but it can also help them see pathways to participate in the transition through employment, innovation, and community action. Education is most powerful when it links climate action to everyday benefits and opportunities.”
Climate
When the Pacific Heats Up: What a Super El Niño Means for India?
Super El Niño may disrupt India’s monsoon, increase heatwaves, and strain the economy. Here’s what it means for climate, agriculture, and growth.
El Niño is a natural climate phenomenon in which surface waters in the central and eastern Pacific Ocean become significantly warmer than average. While El Niño events occur every 2–7 years, a Super El Niño is far more intense, typically marked by unusually high sea surface temperature anomalies (often exceeding +2°C). Climate models indicate a two-in-three chance of a strong to very strong El Niño developing, placing this year in the rare category of “Super El Niño” events, which have occurred only four times since 1950. The most notable recent Super El Niño occurred during 2015–16 and had major global climate impacts. Nearly a decade later, scientists are closely monitoring conditions for signs of a similar event, though its recurrence is not yet certain.
What makes a “Super” El Niño different?
In a normal El Niño, weakened trade winds allow warm water to spread eastward across the Pacific. A Super El Niño amplifies this process, disrupting global atmospheric circulation more dramatically. Global warming is adding further complexity, intensifying heat, altering rainfall patterns, and increasing risks to water, food, and health systems.
There is a recurring pattern where the peak heat impact often follows strong El Niño year, as seen when 2024 became the hottest year after the 2023 El Niño. Projections for 2026 suggest that the most intense heat may extend into 2027, making the period break the existing record. As a result, the upcoming event may lead to more prolonged and sustained heat stress known to humanity.

What does it mean for India?
For India, a Super El Niño does not have a uniform impact. The risks posed by a potential El Niño go beyond weather disruptions, extending deep into India’s economic stability. As Archana Chaudhary, Associate Director at Climate Trends, explains, “The risk India faces is not simply a weak monsoon or a hot year in isolation. It is a compound shock hitting the Indian economy… If a strong El Niño brings erratic rainfall alongside prolonged heat, while geopolitical tensions keep energy prices elevated, India could face pressure from several directions at once: food inflation, weaker rural demand, lower labour productivity, higher electricity and irrigation costs, water stress for industry and rising fiscal burdens.”
While parts of Maharashtra and Uttarakhand have experienced lower rainfall, water shortages, and warmer conditions, regions in the Northeast and along the west coast have received relatively higher rainfall and increased storm activity. Heavy rainfall reported in parts of West Bengal highlights that El Niño does not affect all regions of India in the same way. There are indications that similar uneven patterns could re-emerge. Authorities have urged farmers to be prepared for the kharif season, citing the possibility of variable rainfall conditions.
The Signs of a Pattern Reappearing
Studies show that the 2015 monsoon was significantly below average (around 86% of the long-period average), with rainfall declining after June and showing high variability. This led to drought-like conditions in several regions, reduced soil moisture, and stress on kharif crops. At the same time, India experienced one of its deadliest heatwaves, with temperatures crossing 45°C and causing over 2,500 deaths, particularly in Andhra Pradesh and Telangana.
The emerging 2026 Super El Niño, comparable to the 2015–16 event, is already showing signs of producing similar but more complex impacts on India’s climate. According to the India Meteorological Department, the 2026 southwest monsoon is projected at around 90% of the Long Period Average, with a 60% probability of deficient rainfall, figures close to the deficit observed during 2015. However, unlike 2015, when the impact was seen primarily as a widespread rainfall deficit and deadly heatwaves, current projections highlight greater intra-seasonal variability, with longer dry spells,break-monsoon conditions, and uneven rainfall distribution. Experts also warn that delayed monsoon progression could trigger humid heatwaves across northwest India. while the event may push 2026–27 toward record global and national temperatures.
Strain on India’s Climate Systems
According to scientists at the India Meteorological Department (IMD), El Niño is “one of the most important Ocean–atmosphere phenomena influencing the Indian monsoon,” but it does not act alone. There are also other factors at play, such as the Indian Ocean Dipole (IOD) and regional circulation patterns. They can either amplify or offset its effects.
Super El Niño increases the probability of climatic stress. Overlapping challenges from fuel price volatility and supply disruptions to climate extremes are growing more difficult to address in tandem. The combined pressure of heat, low rainfall and global economic shocks is pushing India’s already stretched systems toward greater instability. With rising baseline temperatures, even a typical El Niño can now produce more extreme outcomes, making preparedness, water management, and climate-resilient agriculture increasingly critical.
-
Society6 months agoThe Ten-Rupee Doctor Who Sparked a Health Revolution in Kerala’s Tribal Highlands
-
Space & Physics1 month agoIndia Semiconductor Mission: ‘It’s Not About Fabs. It’s About Building An Entire Ecosystem’
-
Climate4 weeks agoThe Climate World Cup? How Climate Change Could Affect Player Performance at the 2026 World Cup
-
Society2 weeks agoFrom Bell Labs to the Classroom: A Second Career in Teaching
-
Space & Physics4 weeks agoEngineers Develop Dual-Mode Propulsion System for Next-Generation Small Satellites
-
Interviews5 months agoGeometry, Curiosity and Finding ‘Her’ Place
-
Space & Physics2 months agoInside India’s Semiconductor Push: ‘This Is a 100-Year Bet’
-
Society3 weeks agoFrom One Roman Classroom to 60,000 Schools: How Maria Montessori Quietly Changed the World


