Climate
ESG Narratives and the Talk–Walk Gap: Why Climate Commitments Still Fall Short
As ESG rhetoric becomes increasingly sophisticated, measurable climate outcomes continue to lag behind corporate promises. From net-zero pledges to digital green narratives, the growing “Talk–Walk Gap” raises urgent questions about accountability, transparency, and the future credibility of global sustainability commitments.
The end of 2025 marks the close of another chapter in which much of the global discourse appears to have grown comfortable with ESG (Environmental Social Governance) messaging, even as its tangible impact remains uncertain. What was once framed as a pathway toward an eco-friendly and socially responsible future increasingly risks stagnating as an idealistic, almost utopian concept.
Corporations, meanwhile, have become adept at constructing environments where ESG strategies are articulated confidently but seldom questioned. Sustainability reports are published, climate targets are announced, and long-term commitments are projected — yet the link between these narratives and measurable environmental outcomes often remains unclear.
As debates around ESG continue to unfold in the background, it becomes crucial to ask a more fundamental question: does corporate ESG practice genuinely seek to serve society in a holistic sense, or does it primarily operate to protect vested interests? Examining ESG narratives and their real-world implications is therefore essential, particularly given the immediacy and evolving nature of today’s climate and sustainability challenges.
Current Relevance and Importance
The relevance of this discussion intensifies amid the ongoing COP30 controversy, where the participation of major contributors to environmental instability has drawn global attention. Many of the actors shaping climate discourse continue to represent high-emission industries, raising concerns about how environmental threats are increasingly reframed as economic opportunities.
Factual investigations by Climate Action Against Disinformation (CAAD) offer a close-range view of how digital platforms were leveraged in the run-up to the summit. Their recent report documents how major oil companies made extensive use of Google’s advertising ecosystem, pursuing an aggressive strategy to influence online climate narratives. As of October 2025, oil company advertisements increased globally by 218%, while ads specifically targeting Brazil surged by 2,900%.
Company-level data further illustrates the scale of this intervention. Advertising activity by Saudi Aramco rose by 469.2% month-on-month in October, alongside significant increases by TotalEnergies (106.5%) and ExxonMobil (156.3%). Together, these patterns highlight the extent to which corporate actors can shape climate discourse during moments of heightened political attention (CAAD).
Parallel concerns were reflected in the Statement of Commitment on Climate Information Integrity in Digital Advertising, launched at COP30, which drew attention to climate-related advertising that disseminates misleading narratives, erodes public trust, and operates with limited transparency. The issue of climate disinformation is no longer abstract; it is observable, measurable, and increasingly consequential for public understanding and democratic accountability.
COP30, as a global stage for climate action, therefore also exposed the limits of information transparency in digital ecosystems. The prevalence of paid green narratives and strategic messaging raises questions about whose interests are amplified and whose are marginalised. In such settings, sustainability narratives function less as instruments of accountability and more as strategic proclamations designed to preserve influence and legitimacy, widening the distance between climate ambition and climate action.
Net Zero Commitments vs Net Zero Outcomes
Data from the Net Zero Tracker — a joint initiative of the Energy & Climate Intelligence Unit (ECIU), Data-Driven EnviroLab, the NewClimate Institute, and the University of Oxford — illustrates this imbalance clearly. The analysis indicates that 62.7% of companies actively communicate net-zero intentions through strategy, pledges, or proposed targets, yet fail to provide verifiable evidence of achievement. In contrast, only a negligible fraction of firms can demonstrate externally validated net-zero outcomes, based on an assessment of the world’s 2,000 largest publicly listed companies by annual revenue (Net Zero Tracker, 2024–2025 dataset).
This disparity suggests that ESG communication, in many cases, operates as a narrative exercise rather than a performance-driven framework. The widening gap between declared intent and measurable delivery makes it imperative to examine what can be described as the “Talk–Walk Gap” — the divergence between sustainability messaging and substantive environmental action.
Combining Next-Generation AI and ESG Accountability
Artificial Intelligence, particularly Natural Language Processing (NLP), offers a practical mechanism for analysing this gap. Repetition across CSR reports, sustainability disclosures, and corporate press releases can be systematically examined to identify patterns of narrative reuse rather than strategic progression.
Through techniques that assess verbal mimicry, keyword recurrence, and semantic similarity, NLP can help distinguish genuine ESG evolution from recycled sustainability rhetoric. When ESG language remains largely unchanged across reporting cycles, despite shifting climate risks and regulatory expectations, it raises questions about whether commitments are being operationalised or merely reiterated.
Such analytical tools allow consumers, investors, and policymakers to make more informed decisions. Importantly, they reduce the likelihood that green financing instruments and green bonds are used merely as tools of financial leverage rather than vehicles for genuine environmental transition. In this sense, AI does not replace accountability; it strengthens transparency by exposing inconsistencies between communication and action.
Aftermath
The implications of weak ESG accountability extend beyond corporate strategy and into everyday life. Sustainability narratives increasingly shape consumption patterns, influencing how products and technologies are marketed and normalised within ordinary lifestyles. From energy-intensive appliances to digitally driven conveniences, ESG claims often accompany commodities whose environmental alignment remains unclear.

Whether such practices genuinely contribute to global sustainability objectives — including UN Sustainable Development Goals 7 (Affordable and Clean Energy) and 12 (Responsible Consumption and Production) — remains uncertain within the current corporate landscape. Society itself becomes an unwitting participant in this system, reinforcing narratives without adequate mechanisms for verification.
In an era increasingly shaped by generative AI, the need to detect misalignment between corporate objectives, policy commitments, and actual performance becomes more pressing. While these technologies can be used to amplify corporate messaging, they can also be deployed in the public interest — as tools to flag inconsistencies, assess credibility, and strengthen accountability across ESG ecosystems.
The integration of AI into ESG governance is not without risk, and it requires clear ethical boundaries, institutional oversight, and internationally aligned standards. Frameworks developed by internal governance bodies, alongside external institutions such as the United Nations, can help ensure that AI serves as a mechanism for transparency rather than a vehicle for strategic distortion.
This underscores the growing importance of collective scrutiny and informed engagement with ESG principles. Understanding how sustainability is communicated, validated, and implemented is not merely a corporate concern, but a societal one. Addressing the Talk–Walk Gap therefore requires sustained evaluation, improved verification, and transparent progress — not abrupt disruption, but deliberate and accountable change.
Climate
How Assam’s Recurrent Floods Are Becoming an Economic Burden
Assam’s recurrent floods are creating a growing economic burden, from ₹200 crore in estimated annual losses to 4.27 lakh hectares of land lost to erosion since 1950. As rainfall patterns shift and compound flooding intensifies, the state faces rising risks to livelihoods, infrastructure and development.
Floods are a recurring part of life in Assam. Every monsoon, the Brahmaputra and its tributaries spill into the state’s floodplains, disrupting agriculture, damaging infrastructure and forcing communities to move. But each flood leaves behind more than waterlogged fields and damaged roads. It also leaves an economic bill.
On average, floods inundate 9.31 lakh hectares of Assam every year, according to the state government. Nearly 40% of the state’s land area is flood-prone, while average annual flood losses are estimated at around INR 200 crore. Riverbank erosion adds a more permanent cost. According to report by Climate Central, Assam has lost nearly 4.27 lakh hectares of land since 1950, equivalent to about 7.4% of its geographical area.
The cost does not end when the water recedes. Floods repeatedly disrupt agriculture, tea plantations, fisheries, transport and livelihoods. When a river changes course and takes away farmland, the loss can last for generations. Homes disappear, productive land shrinks and families are forced to start again elsewhere.
The scale of displacement shows how closely the human and economic costs are linked. In 2024, floods in Assam triggered an estimated 2.5 million internal displacements, accounting for nearly half of all disaster-related displacements recorded in India that year.
For a state that has learned to live with floods, the bigger challenge is now managing the repeated economic shocks they create.
When Floods Become Compound
Assam’s floods are rarely the result of one factor alone. Increasingly, several processes can come together to push rivers beyond their limits. Scientists describe this as compound flooding—when multiple sources contribute to flooding at the same time.
Heavy rainfall over Assam can coincide with intense precipitation upstream in Arunachal Pradesh, Bhutan and Tibet. Snow and glacier melt in the eastern Himalayas add seasonal runoff, while swollen tributaries, landslides and riverbank erosion can make the situation worse. The result can be higher flood peaks and longer periods of inundation.
The economic consequences can also multiply. Heavy rain may destroy crops, while rising river levels erode farmland and damage roads. A washed-out bridge can disrupt the movement of food and goods. A flooded market can stop local businesses from operating. For families dependent on daily wages, even a few days without work can mean lost income. In other words, the flood may last days, but its economic effects can last much longer.

A River that Keeps Reshaping the Economy
The Brahmaputra basin stretches across China, Bhutan, India and Bangladesh, covering approximately 650,000 square kilometres. Once the river enters India, it travels for about 710 kilometres through the Assam Valley.
It is a river in constant motion. The Brahmaputra carries huge quantities of sediment from the Himalayas, creating braided channels, shifting sandbars and constantly changing riverbanks.
For Assam, this makes flooding different from a short-lived disaster. The river does not simply cover the land; it can redraw the map.
Assam has lost approximately 4.27 lakh hectares of land to erosion since 1950. The loss is not merely geographical. Farmland disappears, homes are displaced and established settlements can be cut off or forced to move. With the land goes the economic activity that depended on it.
Climate projections suggest that these pressures could intensify. The Assam State Action Plan on Climate Change projects a 5–38% increase in extreme rainfall events and more than a 25% rise in flood events under future climate scenarios. Models also project around a 13% increase in the Brahmaputra’s annual streamflow, while sediment loads could rise by nearly 40% by the end of the century.
If these projections materialise, Assam could face more frequent flooding alongside growing pressure on land, infrastructure and livelihoods.
The Himalayan Connection
The economic risks in Assam begin much farther upstream. The Hindu Kush Himalayan Assessment projects that even if global warming is limited to 1.5°C, at least one-third of the region’s glacier volume could disappear by 2100. Under higher-emission scenarios, glacier losses could exceed 50–65%.
In the short term, warmer temperatures can accelerate snow and glacier melt, increasing runoff. Over time, continued glacier retreat could alter the timing and volume of water entering the river system. Rainfall patterns are changing too. A systematic review cited in the document points to a possible shift in peak rainfall from July to August, along with increasing post-monsoon rainfall and declining pre-monsoon rainfall.
That matters because when rain falls can be as important as how much falls. More intense rainfall can produce sharper flood peaks and leave less time for water to drain.
As Mahesh Palawat, Vice President–Meteorology and Climate Change at Skymet Weather, notes, increasing rainfall variability and shifting monsoon behaviour are making floods less predictable. For Assam, unpredictability has an economic cost of its own. Farmers need to decide when to sow and harvest. Businesses depend on functioning roads and transport networks. Governments have to plan infrastructure that may need to withstand increasingly uncertain conditions.
The Cost of Exposure
Climate change is only part of the picture. Deforestation, urbanisation and unplanned land-use changes can increase runoff and reduce the landscape’s ability to hold water. Development in flood-prone areas also puts more homes, businesses and infrastructure in harm’s way.
The vulnerability is particularly high in low-lying floodplain and char areas, where communities face both flooding and erosion. Repeated displacement can mean losing homes, productive assets and livelihoods more than once. This is why the economic burden of flooding cannot be measured only by the value of buildings or crops damaged during a flood.
It also includes lost working days, disrupted supply chains, damaged crops, interrupted transport, relocation costs and public spending on repairs and recovery. The estimated INR 200 crore in average annual flood losses therefore represents only part of the wider economic burden.
A Future of More Frequent Shocks
The projections point to a difficult future. Hydrological simulations cited in the document suggest that a flood that currently occurs once every 10 years could occur once every two years by 2080 under high-emission scenarios.
This does not mean every future flood will follow that pattern. But it shows how sharply flood frequency could change. And that raises an economic question that Assam will increasingly have to confront: How often can communities, businesses and governments afford to rebuild?
If floods become more frequent, recovery from one event could overlap with preparation for the next. Money spent repairing roads, restoring farmland and rebuilding homes would have to compete with investments needed for long-term development. The cost of doing nothing could therefore extend well beyond the next flood season.
Reducing the Cost of Living With Floods
Assam cannot stop the Brahmaputra from flooding. But it can reduce the damage and, in turn, reduce the economic cost. That means improving upstream observations and early-warning systems, strengthening data sharing across the Brahmaputra basin and designing infrastructure for future climate risks. Floodplain planning, erosion management and ecosystem protection also need to become part of long-term development planning rather than being treated only as disaster-response measures.
Better forecasts can give communities and businesses more time to move livestock, crops and equipment. Better risk maps can help determine where critical infrastructure should, and should not be built. Protecting natural flood buffers can also help slow runoff and reduce exposure.
As Dr Akshay Deoras, Research Scientist at the National Centre for Atmospheric Science, University of Reading, argues, preparing for Assam’s future floods means accounting for changing rainfall patterns, not simply the total amount of rainfall. The Brahmaputra will continue to shape Assam. Floods will remain part of the state’s geography.
The challenge is to ensure that every flood does not also become another economic setback, another loss of land, another disrupted livelihood, another damaged road and another bill to pay. Living with the Brahmaputra may be unavoidable. Making that relationship increasingly unaffordable is not.
Climate
When the Monsoon Returns, Fear Returns: How Climate Disasters Are Reshaping Mental Health in Himachal Pradesh
In Himachal Pradesh, repeated floods and landslides are reshaping mental health in the mountains — but disaster policy still doesn’t see it.
“As soon as the monsoon arrives, fear spreads across the village. People panic because they have already seen what these rains can do. In 2023 and again in 2025, many families here lost their homes, farmland and orchards to monsoon disasters. The moment it starts raining heavily, everyone fears history will repeat itself.”
Het Ram, a resident of Siraj Valley in Himachal Pradesh’s Mandi district, pauses before adding a detail that has quietly become part of everyday life. Most households in his village now keep their important documents, first-aid kits, clothes, dry food, drinking water, ropes and tarpaulin packed together in one corner of the house, ready to be carried at a moment’s notice if disaster strikes.
“Without our documents, we cannot even claim government compensation,” he says.
Why Himachal Pradesh Floods Continue to Haunt Survivors
Het Ram’s experience is shared by families across many villages in Himachal Pradesh, where the monsoon — once welcomed as a season of abundance — has increasingly become synonymous with fear. With the first spell of July rain comes an unspoken anxiety that settles over entire communities. People’s eyes remain fixed not on the clouds but on the fragile mountain slopes towering above their homes. A spell of intense rainfall is enough to keep families awake through the night. Fluctuating blood pressure, panic attacks, insomnia and chronic stress have gradually become a routine part of life in the state’s vulnerable mountain settlements.

Psychologists describe this condition as anticipatory anxiety — the distress that emerges not after a traumatic event but from the constant fear that it may happen again. A study of disaster survivors in Uttarakhand found that repeated exposure to natural disasters leaves people in a permanent state of hypervigilance: interrupted sleep, startling at the slightest sound, and feeling anxious the moment it begins to rain had become routine for many of those affected.
‘I fear the mountain above my home may collapse’

For 56-year-old Chudamani of Sarpada village in Rampur subdivision, July is no longer just another month — it is a season of dread.
Whenever it rains, sleep deserts her. She spends hours sitting outside her house, her eyes fixed on the hillside looming overhead. A single fear keeps returning: What if the mountain gives way? What if everything is gone within seconds?
The fear has haunted her ever since the devastating flash floods of July 2024, when a swollen Samej Khad swept away both her two-storey house and her vehicle.
“Nowhere feels safe anymore,” says her husband, Chatar Singh. “The moment the rains begin, fear settles into our minds. Every spell of heavy rain makes us wonder which family’s home will be destroyed next.”
The scale of destruction behind the anxiety
According to the Himachal Pradesh State Disaster Management Authority, 2,108 people lost their lives during the monsoon seasons between 2020 and 2025, while property worth thousands of crores of rupees was destroyed.
The 2023 monsoon alone claimed 404 lives, left 38 people missing and forced more than 50,000 people to abandon their homes. A total of 2,546 houses were completely destroyed and another 10,853 suffered partial damage. Overall losses crossed INR 12,000 crore.

On August 14, 2023, a landslide in Shimla city killed 20 people. The following year, a cloudburst in the Samej area of Shimla district triggered flash floods that washed away 32 houses and claimed 36 lives. These recurring disasters across Shimla, Mandi and Kullu districts have left behind more than physical and economic devastation — every monsoon now revives memories of loss, uncertainty and the fear of losing loved ones all over again.
‘Not even a needle found after floods’
Alok Kumar of Sarpada village in Rampur embodies the depth of this trauma.
His ancestral home in Samej village was completely washed away in the 2024 floods. His mother and eight tenants lost their lives in the disaster.
“The flood was so devastating that not even a needle remained from our 21-room house,” he recalls. “I still haven’t recovered from that tragedy. Every time I hear about floods or landslides, the entire scene flashes before my eyes. We live in the mountains, so there is always the fear that another disaster could strike at any time.”
He says disasters have become an annual reality.
“For the last three years, something has happened every monsoon. It has increased stress and anxiety among almost everyone in the village. Even the elderly say they have never witnessed anything like this before.”
Despite struggling emotionally, Alok has never sought professional help. Like many others in disaster-prone regions, he considers such distress an unavoidable part of life in the hills.
What doctors are seeing
Mental health professionals in Himachal Pradesh say the psychological toll of climate disasters is becoming more visible, even though systematic evidence from the state is still lacking.
Dr Dinesh Dutt, a psychiatrist at Indira Gandhi Medical College (IGMC), Shimla, says climate change is directly influencing people’s mental well-being.
“Climate has a direct impact on mental health. After monsoon disasters, many survivors continue to relive the traumatic event. Distressing thoughts, memories and images keep recurring in their minds. Clinically, we recognise these symptoms as anxiety and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). We are seeing such cases in hospitals, and our assessments suggest that climate-related events are contributing to these psychological conditions. However, there is still no systematic research that conclusively establishes this link in Himachal Pradesh.”
He adds that the state currently lacks a comprehensive database documenting climate-related mental health cases.
The concerns raised by clinicians are echoed in scientific literature. A review published in Frontiers in Public Health (2025) found that sudden climate-related disasters such as floods, landslides and cyclones frequently lead to PTSD and acute anxiety, while repeated exposure to such events has been associated with depression, hopelessness and, in some cases, suicidal thoughts. Mental health experts believe a similar pattern is gradually emerging in the rural regions of Himachal Pradesh.
Children are carrying the burden too
The psychological impact of recurring disasters is becoming increasingly visible among children.
Mukta, a government schoolteacher in Rohru, says classroom behaviour has changed noticeably since the devastating monsoon of 2023.
“Children have become frightened of the rains. During heavy rainfall, some of them become unusually quiet. Since Rohru is an apple-growing region, many children also worry that their family’s orchards and livelihoods may be destroyed.”
Poonam’s ten-year-old daughter, who lives in Shimla, has also developed an intense fear of the monsoon. Their residential building was declared unsafe after a landslide last year, forcing the family to live with relatives for ten days.
“Since that incident, she has developed a deep sense of insecurity,” Poonam says. “Every time it starts raining, that fear returns.”
For teenagers, the consequences are often less visible but equally profound.
Ashish Dogra, a Class XII student from Ramnagar in Shimla, says the rainy season has transformed childhood routines.
“During the monsoon, no one goes out to play anymore. We stay indoors all day. We talk to friends on the phone, but after a while it becomes boring. Sometimes that isolation makes us irritable and angry.”
Psychologist Neelam Bali says children’s emotional responses are closely linked to the anxiety they observe within their own families.
“When children see their parents constantly worried, they internalise that stress. Most are unable to express their emotions openly, and over time the anxiety begins to show in their behaviour. It eventually affects their studies and overall school performance.”
She emphasises that parents need to encourage open conversations with children.
“Play is one of the most effective ways for children to cope with stress. If they remain cut off from outdoor activities for long periods, they are more likely to experience loneliness, irritability and anger.”
Dr Dutt adds that climate disasters affect children, adults and older people in different ways. “If survivors do not receive timely psychological first aid, the long-term health consequences can be significant.”
When landscapes become a source of grief
Natural disasters alter far more than homes, roads and livelihoods. They also transform people’s emotional relationship with the landscapes they have known all their lives.
When the mountains that once symbolised safety and belonging suddenly become a source of destruction, recovering emotionally is rarely easy.
Researchers describe this experience as solastalgia — the distress people feel when the environment they identify as home is damaged or transformed. Unlike nostalgia, which is a longing for a place left behind, solastalgia emerges while people remain in the very place they call home, watching it deteriorate around them. Over time, this distress can deepen into prolonged grief, anxiety and depression.
Shifting homes in search of safety
Discussions around migration from Himachal Pradesh’s hill districts have traditionally centred on employment, education and infrastructure. But a new driver is quietly emerging: the search for psychological security.
For some families, the fear of living in disaster-prone areas has become so overwhelming that they are abandoning ancestral homes for places they perceive to be safer.
Prabhat Chand, 47, a government school lecturer from Rampur, is one such resident. After the devastating floods in Samej, he decided to leave the area and build a new home nearly 17 kilometres away in Sarpada village.

“Most of the families affected by the disaster have moved elsewhere,” he says. “The flood was so destructive that the place no longer feels fit for habitation.”
Ruchi, who lives in Tutu on the outskirts of Shimla, also shifted to another rented house after repeated monsoon scares. Her previous home stood beside a seasonal stream, and every spell of heavy rainfall made her anxiety worse.
“Whenever I saw news reports of rain-related disasters, I became anxious. Watching the water level in the stream rise only intensified that fear,” she says.
Although she still worries during the monsoon, moving to a different neighbourhood has eased the constant panic she once experienced.
Mental health remains missing from disaster response
Himachal Pradesh has made significant progress in recognising the health risks posed by climate change. The state has adopted the State Action Plan on Climate Change and Human Health (2022–27) and established a Climate Change and Human Health Cell to strengthen public health preparedness.

The plan focuses on physical health, disease surveillance, healthcare infrastructure resilience, early warnings and logistics, but does not address mental health support or psychological care for disaster-affected populations.
While the Climate Change and Human Health Cell provides training to healthcare workers and Accredited Social Health Activists (ASHAs) on mental health and psychological first aid, experts say these efforts have yet to translate into meaningful support on the ground.
Dr Sanjay Pathak, former Director of the Himachal Pradesh Mental Health Authority, believes disaster management continues to prioritise physical rehabilitation over psychological recovery.
“Government responses after disasters understandably focus on relief and rehabilitation,” he says. “But very little attention is paid to what kind of psychological intervention survivors require. Unless mental health becomes an integral part of disaster response, people will continue to live with a persistent sense of insecurity.”
Dr Dutt points to another challenge: the severe shortage of trained mental health professionals.
“The frequency of disasters is increasing much faster than our capacity to provide psychological support. For now, community and family networks are helping people cope. But as those social structures weaken, the need for professional mental health services will become much greater.”
The policy gap extends beyond Himachal Pradesh. An analysis published by the Observer Research Foundation (ORF) notes that disaster management strategies in India remain largely centred on rescue operations, rehabilitation and rebuilding infrastructure, with mental health support yet to be systematically integrated into these frameworks. The analysis also found that psychological disorders following natural disasters are 40 per cent more common than physical injuries — underscoring the need to treat mental health as a core part of disaster preparedness and recovery.
What needs to change?
Both Dr Pathak and Dr Dutt agree that psychosocial care must become a standard part of emergency relief rather than an afterthought. They identify three immediate priorities: training schoolteachers to provide basic psychosocial support to children affected by disasters; strengthening the capacity of ASHA workers and frontline health personnel to identify and respond to psychological distress; and expanding access to counselling and mental health services in disaster-affected communities.
For a Himalayan state facing ever more frequent extreme weather, integrating mental health into disaster management is no longer simply a public health recommendation — it is a necessity.
As climate change continues to reshape the mountains, it is also reshaping the emotional landscape of the people who call them home. The landslides and floods may disappear once the rains recede, but for many survivors, the fear remains — returning every monsoon, long before the first cloudburst.
Raman Kant is a mentee at the Asian College of Journalism’s Climate Change Media Hub, supported by Interlink Academy, Germany.
Climate
Delhi’s Air Pollution: Climate Change Is Raising Risks for India’s Heritage
India’s heritage sites are facing growing environmental risks as air pollution, rising temperatures, changing rainfall and coastal exposure accelerate the deterioration of historic structures. From pollution-linked black crusts at Humayun’s Tomb to salt damage at Mahabalipuram’s Shore Temple, scientific studies show why climate and environmental monitoring are becoming increasingly important for heritage conservation.
Delhi’s air pollution is damaging more than the city’s air quality. It is also contributing to the slow deterioration of its built heritage. India’s historic monuments are facing an environmental threat that extends beyond age and neglect. Air pollution, extreme weather, changing rainfall, rising temperatures and coastal hazards are creating new challenges for conserving structures built under very different environmental conditions.
A new study of Humayun’s Tomb in Delhi provides a close look at one of these risks. Researchers from IIT Roorkee and IIT Kanpur found that air pollution is contributing to the formation of black crusts on the sandstone surfaces of the UNESCO World Heritage Site. The study found that these crusts contain gypsum, carbon-rich material and traces of metals associated with urban pollution.
The finding is significant because it shows how environmental conditions around a monument can gradually alter its materials. But Humayun’s Tomb is only one example of a wider conservation challenge.
Pollution Leaves a Chemical Mark
Researchers collected five black-crust samples from rain-sheltered rooftop locations at Humayun’s Tomb under the supervision of an Archaeological Survey of India conservator. Using techniques including XRF, XRD, FTIR, SEM-EDX, CHNS and ICP-MS, the researchers found gypsum to be the dominant mineral in the crust. They concluded that external sources of calcium, including airborne particles, react with sulphur compounds to produce gypsum on the sandstone.
The composition also contained indicators consistent with pollution from vehicles, road and soil dust, construction, biomass burning and industrial activity. Crust formation was stronger at locations exposed to wind but sheltered from rain, showing that both pollution and local exposure conditions influence deterioration.

The study does not establish that the black crust itself has caused structural failure of Humayun’s Tomb. Instead, it identifies a long-term material deterioration process and recommends preventive conservation, including scientifically established cleaning methods, site-specific testing of protective coatings, air-quality monitoring and atmospheric modelling.
The Taj Mahal Shows How Pollution Affects Heritage
Humayun’s Tomb is not the only Indian monument where air pollution has been studied as a conservation concern. A 2015 study in Environmental Science & Technology measured particulate pollution around the Taj Mahal over a year and found high levels of light-absorbing particles, including black carbon, brown carbon and dust. Experiments using marble surrogate surfaces showed that these carbon-rich particles contribute to surface discoloration.
However, this finding is specific to staining and surface change. It does not imply that air pollution alone explains all forms of deterioration at the Taj Mahal. Recognising pollution as a conservation issue, the Ministry of Culture reports that the Archaeological Survey of India operates air-pollution monitoring laboratories at the Taj Mahal and Bibi ka Maqbara.
Climate Conditions Monuments Face
Climate change presents a different, but overlapping, conservation problem. UNESCO identifies storms, cyclones and tidal surges as potential threats to the World Heritage property and notes that their frequency could increase as a result of climate change.
A major review of climate-change impacts on cultural heritage found that climate change can alter the frequency and intensity of processes that already damage historic materials. These include moisture-related deterioration, salt crystallisation, biological growth and erosion. The review stresses that the effects vary according to the material, location and local climate of each heritage site.
That makes it important not to treat climate change as a single threat to India’s monuments. A stone temple on the coast faces different risks from a sandstone monument in Delhi or a heritage structure in a flood-prone region.
Mahabalipuram: Salt and Sea Exposure
The Shore Temple at Mahabalipuram illustrates the vulnerability of coastal heritage. A study by researchers from ASI and the National Museum Institute examined the deterioration of the 7th–8th-century granite monument. Extensive salt-induced deterioration, particularly on sections directly exposed to the sea. Some sculptures on the seaward side had been eroded beyond recognition.
The study linked the deterioration to marine exposure, sea spray, soluble salts, high-velocity winds and the site’s tropical, humid conditions. The researchers also found that continuous sea spray makes some conventional stone-conservation approaches difficult to maintain.
The study does not establish that climate change caused the Shore Temple’s existing deterioration. It does, however, demonstrate how vulnerable coastal heritage can be to marine and climatic conditions; risks that become increasingly important as coastal environments change.
Importance of Preventive Conservation
India has already begun incorporating environmental monitoring into heritage conservation. The Ministry of Culture said in that ASI and ISRO have installed Automated Weather Stations at several historical monuments to track temperature, rainfall and wind. ASI also carries out periodic scientific treatment and conservation work at heritage sites.
But the evidence from Humayun’s Tomb shows that monitoring pollution and climate variables must be paired with material-level studies. The challenge is identifying the environmental drivers of deterioration and intervening early, before it becomes irreversible.
For Delhi, this means reducing pollutants that settle on historic stone. Coastal monuments must contend with salt, moisture and erosion, while high-rainfall regions require stronger drainage and structural resilience.
-
Math2 weeks agoThe 2026 Fields Medals: Four Proofs, Four Decades-Old Problems Solved
-
Climate2 weeks agoAfter Kerala’s Deadliest Landslide, the Hardest Thing to Rebuild Was Childhood
-
Society1 month agoWest Asia Crisis: Can Kerala’s Returning Gulf Migrants Find a Future in the Green Economy?
-
Space & Physics2 months agoIndia Semiconductor Mission: ‘It’s Not About Fabs. It’s About Building An Entire Ecosystem’
-
Climate2 months agoThe Climate World Cup? How Climate Change Could Affect Player Performance at the 2026 World Cup
-
Society4 weeks agoWhat Is Civilisational Diplomacy? Understanding India’s Newest Foreign Policy Tool
-
Society2 months agoFrom Bell Labs to the Classroom: A Second Career in Teaching
-
Space & Physics2 months agoEngineers Develop Dual-Mode Propulsion System for Next-Generation Small Satellites


