Connect with us

Society

Reborn; India’s 1600-year-old Ivy League University

Thousands of years ago, Nalanda was burnt to ashes. Today, from those ashes, a new Nalanda is rising. The new campus of Nalanda has been built at a cost of Rs 1,800 crore.

Published

on

nalanda
Image credit: Nalanda University

Once a beacon of knowledge, Nalanda University stood as one of the most prestigious educational institutions in ancient India. Its halls echoed with the footsteps of scholars from across the world, who came to immerse themselves in diverse fields of study. However, this illustrious centre of learning faced destruction due to foreign invasions, leading to centuries of dormancy.

In a significant turn of events, the echoes of Nalanda’s scholarly past are being rekindled. On June 19, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi inaugurated the new campus of Nalanda University, symbolizing a revival of its 1600-year-old legacy. This modern resurrection aims to restore and celebrate the ancient university’s historical importance while positioning it as a global hub for education once again.

nala
Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi inaugurating the new campus of Nalanda University

Between the 5th and 13th centuries, Nalanda University flourished as a world-renowned institution, earning immense admiration within India’s education system and beyond. Its international reputation attracted students from China, Mongolia, Tibet, Korea, and other Asian countries, all eager to study on its esteemed campus. Known for its high standard of teaching, Nalanda was especially prominent as a centre for Mahayana Buddhist philosophy.

While inaugurating the new campus, the Prime Minister said that Nalanda embodies India’s identity, respect, value and mantra

Ayurveda, Buddhism, Mathematics, Grammar, Astronomy, Indian Philosophy and many other subjects were taught at Nalanda, the world’s first residential university. The famous Indian mathematician Aryabhata was a teacher here in the 6th century. The university’s library, known as Dharma Gunj or the Mountain of Truth, was legendary. It housed an astounding collection of 9 million palm leaf manuscripts, making it one of the most famous libraries of its time.

At the end of the 12th century, Turko-Afghan military general Bakhtiyar Khilji destroyed this great university and burnt its priceless library. Considering the fact that ancient Nalanda was a symbol of Asian unity and strength, now Nalanda International University is being established near the land where the remnants of old Nalanda lie. While inaugurating the new campus, the Prime Minister said that Nalanda embodies India’s identity, respect, value and mantra. Modi inaugurated Nalanda within 10 days of taking oath as Prime Minister for the third time. Central government is giving so much importance to this project.

The idea of reviving Nalanda University took off in 2007 at the Second East Asia Summit when sixteen member countries agreed. In 2009, at the Fourth East Asia Summit, ASEAN member states including Australia, China, Korea, Singapore and Japan pledged their support

Nalanda University is located in Rajgir in Nalanda district of Bihar state. This is a project of special interest to the Ministry of External Affairs. The new campus has been developed with an investment of Rs.1800 crore. It consists of two academic blocks with 40 classrooms with a seating capacity of 1900 students, two auditoriums with a seating capacity of 300 each, a student hostel, an international centre, an amphitheatre with a seating capacity of 2000, a faculty club and a sports complex.

The idea of reviving Nalanda University took off in 2007 at the Second East Asia Summit when sixteen member countries agreed. In 2009, at the Fourth East Asia Summit, ASEAN member states including Australia, China, Korea, Singapore and Japan pledged their support.

The Bihar state government handed over the land acquired from the local people to the university for the new campus. A meeting between Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar and the then External Affairs Minister SM Krishna resulted in the central government assuring adequate funds for the project. The university also aims to serve as a bridge for students from different parts of Southeast Asia.

In 2007, the Bihar Legislative Assembly passed a bill to create a new university. The Nalanda University Bill was passed in the Rajya Sabha (the upper house of India’s Parliament) on 21 August 2010 and in the Lok Sabha (the lower house of India’s Parliament) on 26 August 2010.  The Bill received the President’s assent on 21 September 2010, thereby becoming a law.  The university formally came into existence on 25 November 2010 when the Act was enacted.

EP Staff is the editorial team at EdPublica, an independent media organisation focused on science, education, environment and public policy. The team produces evidence-based news, features, explainers and analysis on issues that shape society and everyday life.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Society

Why Global Tech and Industry Lean on Indian Talent

A look at how cultural roots, rigorous logic, and specialized management education shape a distinct global edge.

Dipin Damodharan

Published

on

featured 8

The modern corporate land scape is undergoing a massive, structural transformation. Across the globe, industries are no longer merely supported by in formation technology; they are entirely defined by it. From algorithmic finance to decentralized operations, “IT has become like a god—like, all-pervad ing,” observes management education expert Bharat Nadkarni.

As every sector moves toward an IT-based core, Indian youngsters have consistently found themselves at the forefront of this digital shift. This glob al positioning is not accidental. It is the result of a unique intersection be tween deep-seated cultural strengths, specialized technical streams, and a fundamentally logic-driven approach to solving problems.

featured 3
Image:David Brown/Pexels

Early Specialization and Management Polish

The journey of an Indian profes sional entering the global workforce typically begins with early academic focus. The current education system is structured to allow students who ex hibit a passion for scientific domains to concentrate deeply and cultivate a strict specialization early on. However, technical expertise alone is rarely enough to drive massive organizations forward. The real leverage happens when this scien tific groundwork is polished through management education.

By picking up the finer operational and structural points of business—whether special izing in strategic finance, logistics and operations, targeted marketing, or human resource frameworks—young professionals learn the art of execut ing at scale. Historically, these business silos operated independently. Today, tech nology acts as the universal connec tive tissue, smoothly binding opera tions, finance, and human resources into a single data-driven ecosystem. Because Indian students are trained to bridge the gap between technical execution and management strategy, they adapt exceptionally well to these interconnected systems.

A 500-Year Heritage of Logic

Beyond specialized academic pipe lines, a far deeper, cultural variable drives this aptitude. According to Nad karni, one of the primary foundational strengths of the demographic is a deeply ingrained ing manifests clearly in the career paths young professionals gravitate toward. Logic-dominant fields—such as advanced software engineering, mathematics, database architecture, and corporate finance—require an innate comfort with structure, pattern recognition, and systemic control. It is a space where clear, algorithmic thinking directly dictates success.capacity for rigorous logic. “Indian students are logically very strong,” Nadkarni explains.

“Maybe it is in our culture, and that culture may be of last 500 years.” This legacy of analytical reasoning manifests clearly in the career paths young professionals gravitate toward. Logic-dominant fields—such as advanced software engineering, mathematics, database architecture, and corporate finance—require an innate comfort with structure, pattern recognition, and systemic control. It is a space where clear, algorithmic thinking directly dictates success.

Navigating an All-Pervading Digital Future

As the international market evolves, the demand for this exact combination of deep logic and tech nical management is accelerating. The global shift toward data-centric business models plays directly to these intrinsic cultural and education al strengths.

For organizations trying to navigate this landscape, the lesson is clear: the strength of the emerging work force lies not just in their familiarity with modern tools, but in the struc tural logic they use to build them. By leveraging a historical foundation of analytical thought and refining it through modern management princi ples, a new generation is proving that they are uniquely equipped to lead an all-pervading digital economy.

Continue Reading

Climate

India tops the world for population exposed to climate-driven risky heat

Climate-driven heat exposed 117 million people in India to a month or more of risky heat between June and August 2026, Climate Central found.

Published

on

climate-driven heat
A woman shields herself from the summer heat on a busy street in India.. Image credit: Anurag Jamwal/Pexels

Climate-driven heat exposed 117 million people in India to a month or more of risky heat between June and August 2026, according to a Climate Central analysis.

Between June and August this year, 117 million people in India spent a month or more under heat that would have been far less likely without a warming planet. That single number, from a new global analysis by Climate Central, puts India at the top of the world’s list for population exposed to climate-driven risky heat — ahead of China’s 94 million and Indonesia’s 83 million.

The finding sits inside a larger, starker pattern. Worldwide, over 1.5 billion people experienced 30 or more days of risky heat that climate change made significantly more likely this summer. On any single day of the season, more than a quarter of humanity felt a strong climate change signal in the local temperature. Climate Central’s scientists tracked this using their Climate Shift Index (CSI), which measures how much more likely a given day’s warmth was because of climate change, and flagged “risky heat days” as those hotter than 90% of what a place recorded between 1991 and 2020 — the threshold at which heat starts to strain the body.

The Global Climate-Driven Heat Scoreboard

Europe came out the most unusually hot continent on the planet this year, even though it was not the most populous one affected. Eighty-nine per cent of Europeans — nearly nine in ten — spent a month or more under risky heat. France and the Holy See tied for the largest temperature anomaly of any country, running 3.5°C above their historical norm, and seven of the world’s ten most abnormally hot countries were European. Fifty-four countries recorded their hottest June-to-August since 1970, France, Italy and the United Kingdom among them.

Asia, by contrast, carried the largest raw number of people through this heat: 2.8 billion, or 58% of the continent’s population, spent 30 days or more under conditions strongly shaped by climate change. India and Egypt were the two countries where more than 100 million people each crossed that threshold.

Africa’s story shows up less in totals and more in persistence. Six African countries spent at least 95% of the entire three-month period under a strong climate change influence — Rwanda for 91 days, Uganda for 89, Ethiopia for 88. For those populations, the season did not have an unusually hot patch; nearly the whole summer was one.

In North America, four in five people in the United States lived through a month’s worth of risky summer heat, with the average American gaining 23 such days from climate change and the average Canadian gaining 17.

India’s numbers, city by city

Nationally, India ran 0.7°C warmer than its 1991–2020 June-to-August average, and the average Indian experienced climate change’s fingerprint on local temperature for 39 days across the three months — better than a third of the entire season.

City-level data obtained alongside the release shows how unevenly that heat landed.

CityStateDays with strong climate signalRisky heat daysRisky heat days added by climate change
MumbaiMaharashtra86244
PuneMaharashtra761717
SuratGujarat74269
BengaluruKarnataka7300
MaduraiTamil Nadu702323
NashikMaharashtra672019
CoimbatoreTamil Nadu6600
VisakhapatnamAndhra Pradesh65219
TiruchirappalliTamil Nadu642929
ChennaiTamil Nadu604030
VijayawadaAndhra Pradesh431810
SrinagarJammu and Kashmir285329

Source: Climate Central, June–August 2026 city dataset.

Two different stories run through these columns, and conflating them misses the point.

Mumbai tops the country for sheer duration: 86 of the 92 days in the season carried a strong climate change signal, more than any other Indian city measured. But of Mumbai’s 24 risky heat days, only four were added by climate change — the city runs hot most of the year regardless, so the climate contribution to its worst days is comparatively small. Pune and Nashik, sitting in Mumbai’s own state, show almost the opposite ratio: nearly every risky heat day they had this summer would not have happened without climate change.

Chennai had both the most risky heat days in the country — 40 — and the most added by climate change — 30. That combination makes it the city where the analysis draws the clearest straight line between a hot summer and a warming climate. Tiruchirappalli and Madurai, both in Tamil Nadu, follow the same pattern: every risky heat day counted in each city was one climate change made more likely.

Srinagar is the outlier worth pausing on. A city known for temperate summers recorded 53 risky heat days, more than any other Indian city in the dataset, of which 29 were attributed to climate change — a scale of departure from its own historical baseline far larger than what Mumbai or Delhi saw from theirs.

Where the heat did not arrive

Not every Indian city ran hotter than usual. Jaipur’s seasonal average came in 0.4°C below its 1991–2020 norm, Kota 0.2°C below, and Bhopal 0.1°C below — small numbers, but real ones, in a summer when most of the country and the world trended the other way. Even so, none of the three escaped the climate signal entirely: Jaipur still logged three risky heat days attributable to climate change, Kota three, Bhopal one. The exceptions are a reminder that a warming climate does not raise every thermometer in lockstep, even as it raises the odds almost everywhere.

What the numbers are measuring

The CSI framework Climate Central uses does not ask whether a heatwave happened — it asks how much more likely climate change made it. A CSI level of 2 or higher, the threshold used throughout this analysis, means the day’s warmth was at least twice as likely because of the human-driven build-up of greenhouse gases. That is a probability statement about cause, not a one-off weather reading, which is what allows the same framework to compare Mumbai’s long hot stretch against Chennai’s sharper, more clearly climate-driven spike.

Kristina Dahl, Climate Central’s vice president for science, described the pattern as one where “human-driven warming is pushing communities beyond safe physical limits” — a line written with Europe and North America in mind as much as South Asia. The India numbers suggest the same pressure is arriving unevenly within a single country: some cities absorbing a long, low-grade climate signal across most of the summer, others taking a shorter but far sharper hit concentrated into their worst weeks.

Continue Reading

Society

Under Lalbagh: How a Botanical Garden Forced Bengaluru to Rethink Its Tunnel Road

The Lalbagh tunnel road project has forced Bengaluru to rethink plans for a proposed tunnel through one of the city’s oldest and most important green spaces. EdPublica visits Lalbagh Botanical Garden and speaks to the people who walk through it every day. The Lalbagh tunnel road has become the clearest test yet of how far public pressure can move a government once a decision looks final.

Dipin Damodharan

Published

on

Lalbagh tunnel road debate
Morning walkers cross Lalbagh Rock's summit, the shrine visible in the distance. The three-billion-year-old Peninsular Gneiss beneath them — often mistaken for granite, but a distinct metamorphic formation — is now at the centre of Bengaluru's tunnel road dispute. Image: Dipin Damodharan/EdPublica

A Rs 17,000-crore-plus tunnel road was meant to cut Bengaluru’s commute times. Instead, it ran into a three-billion-year-old rock — and a government now scrambling to find another way through. EdPublica visits Lalbagh Botanical Garden and speaks to the people who walk through it every day.The Lalbagh tunnel road has become the clearest test yet of how far public pressure can move a government once a decision looks final.

It is early morning at Lalbagh’s West Gate, and walkers are already streaming in — no ticket needed at this hour, the entry stays free until nine. Somewhere past the bougainvillea, the Rose Garden is waking up in the mist, and a flock of parakeets is making its usual racket around the glasshouse. For most of the people filing in, this is simply the start of another day — a walk, a stretch, a bit of quiet before Bengaluru’s traffic takes over. Few of them are thinking about what lies beneath their feet: a proposed ten-lane road tunnel that, on paper, was meant to run straight through this ground.

The autorickshaw driver who dropped this reporter near the gate had his own way of putting it. He’d seen the protest that filled the park on a Sunday morning not long ago — thousands of people, banners, a human chain stretching around the old rock. He didn’t have strong views either way about tunnels and traffic, he said, but he’d noticed something: when the government backed down on the law that triggered it all, and signalled it might route the project around the garden instead of under it, people he spoke to seemed relieved. Since then, he said, he’d been getting more fares to Lalbagh than usual — visitors curious, it seemed, about the garden that had been all over the news.

Rajendar, who lives in Jigani on the city’s southern edge and drives roughly ninety minutes to visit, put it more simply. He comes for the green, he said — for a couple of hours where the air feels different, away from the concrete and the horns. A garden like this, he felt, was not something the city had many more of to spare.

Lalbagh tunnel road
The entrance to Lalbagh Botanical Garden, one of Bengaluru’s historic urban green spaces.
Credit: Dipin Damodharan/EdPublica

Not everyone was willing to be named. A corporate employee, mid-morning break, walking briskly along the lake path, agreed to talk only on condition of anonymity. His view was blunt: whatever the traffic problem is, running infrastructure like this under a garden like Lalbagh is not the way to solve it. The government, he said, needs to reconsider — and find a fix that doesn’t ask a 240-acre lung space to absorb the cost.

A garden older than the city’s traffic problem

Lalbagh’s story predates the automobile by more than a century. Hyder Ali, the ruler of Mysore, laid it out in 1760 as a private garden modelled partly on Mughal design; his son Tipu Sultan expanded it with plants brought back from campaigns and trading contacts across the region. British superintendents took over after, adding the glasshouse in 1890 — built, like much of the era’s civic architecture, in conscious echo of London’s Crystal Palace — and the garden has hosted its twin flower shows around Republic Day and Independence Day ever since.

Today it holds more than 1,850 plant species across 240 acres, including a roughly 250-year-old silk cotton tree said to date to Tipu Sultan’s time, and the Lalbagh Rock — a granite-gneiss outcrop now estimated by geologists to be about three billion years old, among the oldest exposed rock formations anywhere on the peninsula. A watchtower built during the reign of Kempegowda II sits on it. Campaigners have been pushing to have the rock considered for UNESCO recognition, in the same conversation as sites like Hampi.

Untitled design 22
The National Geological Monument marking the Peninsular Gneiss at Lalbagh Botanical Garden, Bengaluru. Credit: Dipin Damodharan/EdPublica

That rock, and the ground around it, is precisely what the tunnel road project has to pass through.

Lalbagh’s fight is, in that sense, a small and very local chapter of a much bigger story. UN-Habitat’s World Cities Report 2024 found that the average share of green space in cities worldwide fell from 19.5 per cent in 1990 to just 13.9 per cent by 2020 — and the decline has been sharper still in this part of the world, with East and Southeast Asia’s urban green cover dropping from 32.5 per cent to 18.6 per cent over the same period. Every city loses its green space to something that looks, at the time, like a reasonable trade-off — a road, a housing block, a transit line. Bengaluru’s version of that trade-off currently runs 50 to 100 feet under a botanical garden.

Lalbagh Tunnel Road: Bengaluru’s Controversial Project Faces a Rethink

What the Lalbagh Tunnel Road Project actually proposes

The Bengaluru Tunnel Road — sometimes called the Twin Tunnel Road — is planned to run 16.5 to 16.75 kilometres between Hebbal in the north and Central Silk Board in the south, largely beneath the Outer Ring Road corridor. Its cost has been quoted at different points as roughly INR 17,000 crore, INR17,698 crore and, more recently, INR 22,267 crore, after Adani Group entities were reported to have won the contract. As originally designed, the alignment required roughly six acres of Lalbagh land — most of it temporary, during construction — for two entry and exit ramps and a ventilation shaft, with one ramp passing within a few hundred metres of Lalbagh Lake and another running close to the rock formation itself, at depths of 50 to 100 feet.

What the reports found

Three separate technical reports have shaped the debate, and none of them offer the government much comfort.

A Geotechnical Interpretative Report prepared for the city’s civic body by Rodic Consultants, dated September 2024, flagged the Lalbagh stretch as a “bedrock transition zone” and noted a geological lineament — a fault-like feature — crossing the proposed alignment near the lake, along with risks of groundwater seepage and seasonal water-table shifts.

A Geological Survey of India expert committee went further. Its report, submitted to the government in April 2026, warned that tunnelling and blasting near the rock could widen existing cracks, destabilise parts of the formation, and disturb groundwater flows into Lalbagh Lake — and separately flagged risk to the historic Kempegowda watchtower. GSI also noted civil-society efforts to have the rock nominated as a UNESCO site.

A third, independent study — by the Sustainable Transportation Lab at the Indian Institute of Science, led by Professor Ashish Verma — questioned the project’s basic logic rather than its geology. Modelling suggested the tunnel would carry only around 1,200 passengers per hour per direction, against roughly 69,000 for a nine-coach metro line built at comparable cost; in a high-toll scenario, the study projected the tunnel’s volume-to-capacity ratio could fall as low as 0.1 — a road built for far more traffic than would likely use it. The same analysis suggested the project could, in some scenarios, add to the city’s overall emissions rather than cut them, by drawing commuters away from mass transit and towards private cars.

The law that lit the fuse

If one thing turned this from a planning dispute into a street movement, it was a single piece of legislation.

The Karnataka Government Parks (Preservation) (Amendment) Bill, 2026, amends a 1975 law that has, until now, given government parks and gardens fairly strong statutory protection. The amendment inserts a new provision allowing the state to “alienate” — that is, sell, lease, gift, exchange, mortgage or otherwise transfer — up to 5 per cent of the total area of any government park or garden in Karnataka, for specified public infrastructure and utility projects. Applied to a 240-acre site like Lalbagh, that threshold works out to roughly 12 acres, twice what the tunnel’s original design was reported to need.

The government’s case is that the change is generic policy, not a Lalbagh-specific fix: Chief Minister D.K. Shivakumar has said it is meant to enable ordinary public works, such as road-widening, without the cost and delay of separately acquiring private land, and that the provision does not open parkland to private developers — land can only be leased, transferred or exchanged to government departments, statutory authorities and local bodies. Critics were not persuaded. The Bill was cleared by the Cabinet and passed by both Houses of the legislature on 24 August 2026 amid opposition protests inside the Assembly and, its critics say, with little substantive debate — timing that, coming as the tunnel’s alignment through Lalbagh was already under challenge in court, read to many as a legislative route around the garden’s protections rather than a coincidence.

Untitled design 21
Lalbagh Lake, part of the garden’s landscape that could be affected by changes to groundwater flows during tunnelling.Credit: Dipin Damodharan/EdPublica

How the fight unfolded

The reaction outside the legislature was faster than the government seemed to expect. Within three days of the Bill’s passage, more than 200 citizens, resident groups and environmental organisations gathered at Lalbagh on 27 August to form a human chain around the ancient rock, demanding the amendment be withdrawn. That Sunday, 30 August, the numbers swelled into the thousands for a march titled “Walk in Lalbagh, Walk for Lalbagh” — residents, walkers’ associations, cycling groups and pro-Kannada organisations alongside Bengaluru South MP Tejasvi Surya, Union Minister Shobha Karandlaje and other BJP lawmakers, plus veteran environmentalist A.N. Yellappa Reddy. Marchers sat and lay across the Peninsular Gneiss rock itself and raised slogans in Kannada and English with a common refrain: not one inch of Lalbagh.

The mobilisation built on opposition that had already been running for months through the courts — public-interest litigation in the Karnataka High Court led in part by theatre personality Prakash Belawadi and civic figures including Adikesavalu Ravindra and N.S. Mukunda, and an earlier, smaller human chain in early August aimed specifically at protecting the geological monument from the tunnel.

Facing that pressure, and with BJP leaders petitioning the Governor to withhold assent to the Bill, the state Cabinet withdrew it within days, on 3 September 2026. Shivakumar said the legislation would be reintroduced later, after wider public consultation — it has not been dropped for good. A week after that, on 9 September, he went a step further and said he had asked Greater Bengaluru Development Minister Krishna Byre Gowda to study alternatives to using Lalbagh land for the tunnel. That is an instruction to examine options, not a decision to reroute — no revised alignment has been published, and the original six-acre land requirement, the detailed project report and the tender awarded to Adani entities all remain officially in force.

Several petitioners have said they intend to keep challenging the project on transport and procedural grounds regardless of what happens to the amendment or the alignment. Their case — over the withheld 2025 expert report, the missing environmental impact assessment and questions about statutory transport-authority approvals — is due back before the Karnataka High Court in December.

Why the green matters, in numbers

  • 240 acres — Lalbagh’s total area, one of the two largest green lungs in central Bengaluru alongside Cubbon Park.
  • 1,850+ plant species recorded in the garden, built up over roughly 265 years by Mysore rulers, British superintendents and the state horticulture department.
  • ~3 billion years — estimated age of the Lalbagh Rock, a Peninsular Gneiss formation and protected National Geological Monument.
  • 16.5–16.75 km — length of the proposed tunnel road corridor between Hebbal and Silk Board.
  • ~6 acres — Lalbagh land originally required for the tunnel’s ramps and ventilation shaft.
  • 1,200 vs 69,000 — projected passengers-per-hour-per-direction for the tunnel versus a comparably priced metro line, per the IISc study.
  • INR 1,000 crore/km — estimated tunnel construction cost, against roughly ₹500 crore/km for metro and INR 110 crore/km for suburban rail, by the same analysis.

A retreat, not a resolution

For now, the garden itself shows no sign of the fight above and around it. The lake is calm, the rock still draws its usual scatter of visitors reading the noticeboard about its age, and the morning walkers keep coming. What has shifted is something real but narrower than it looks: a government caught off guard by how fast a legislative manoeuvre turned into a mass protest, and forced into a public climbdown within ten days of passing a law.

That is not the same as Lalbagh being safe. The amendment is shelved, not repealed, and Shivakumar has said it will return after “consultation.” The instruction to study a route around the garden is exactly that — a study, with no published alternative and no change yet to the project’s land requirement, tender or contractor. The Geological Survey of India’s warnings about the rock, the watchtower and the groundwater, submitted in April and made public only in September, have not been formally answered. And the oldest thread of opposition — the court case over how the project was tendered and cleared in the first place — continues in December, indifferent to whichever way the alignment eventually bends.

So the honest answer, for Rajendar driving in from Jigani, or for the corporate employee unwilling to give his name, is not that they won. It is that a fight most people assumed was already lost turned out not to be — and that the next few months, in a courtroom and in a minister’s office rather than at a human chain, will decide whether that counts for anything.

Continue Reading

Trending