Connect with us

Space & Physics

S N Bose – the world’s most underrated quantum maestro 

There are plenty of scientists across the world from history, across the colonial era and beyond – which this ‘Know the Scientist’ page seeks to shed light on. It’s through us retelling these stories time and again do their experiences become immortalized in time for us to understand. 

Karthik Vinod

Published

on

KNOW THE SCIENTIST

It’s 1924, and Satyendra Nath Bose, going by S.N. Bose was a young physicist teaching in Dhaka, then British India. Grappled by an epiphany, he was desperate to have his solution, fixing a logical inconsistency in Planck’s radiation law, get published. He had his eyes on the British Philosophical Magazine, since word could spread to the leading physicists of the time, most if not all in Europe. But the paper was rejected without any explanations offered. 

WhatsApp Image 2024 02 08 at 14.24.39

But he wasn’t going to give up just yet. Unrelenting, he sent another sealed envelope with his draft and this time a cover letter again, to Europe. One can imagine months later, Bose breathing out a sigh of relief when he finally got a positive response – from none other than the great man of physics himself – Albert Einstein. 

In some ways, Bose and Einstein were similar. Both had no PhDs when they wrote their treatises that brought them into limelight. And Einstein introduced E=mc2 derived from special relativity with little fanfare, so did Bose who didn’t secure a publisher with his groundbreaking work that invented quantum statistics. He produced a novel derivation of the Planck radiation law, from the first principles of quantum theory. 

This was a well-known problem that had plagued physicists since Max Planck, the father of quantum physics himself. Einstein himself had struggled time and again, to only have never resolved the problem. But Bose did, and too nonchalantly with a simple derivation from first principles grounded in quantum theory. For those who know some quantum theory, I’m referring to Bose’s profound recognition that the Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution that holds true for ideal gasses, fails for quantum particles. A technical treatment of the problem would reveal that photons, that are particles of light with the same energy and polarization, are indistinguishable from each other, as a result of the Pauli exclusion principle and Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle. 

Fascinated and moved by what he read, Einstein was magnanimous enough to have Bose’s paper translated in German and published in the journal, Zeitschrift für Physik in Germany the same year. It would be the beginning of a brief, but productive professional collaboration between the two theoretical physicists, that would just open the doors to the quantum world much wider. Fascinatingly, this July will mark the 100 years since Einstein submitted Bose’s paper, “Planck’s law and the quantum hypothesis” on his behalf to Zeitschrift fur Physik. 

With the benefit of hindsight, Bose’s work was really nothing short of revolutionary for its time. However, a Nobel Committee member, the Swedish Oskar Klein – and theoretical physicist of repute – deemed it a mere advance in applied sciences, rather than a major conceptual advance. With hindsight again, it’s a known fact that Nobel Prizes are handed in for quantum jumps in technical advancements more than ever before. In fact, the 2001 Nobel Prize in Physics went to Carl Wieman, Eric Allin Cornell, and Wolfgang Ketterle for synthesizing the Bose-Einstein condensate, a prediction made actually by Einstein based on Bose’s new statistics. These condensates are created when atoms are cooled to near absolute zero temperature, thus attaining the quantum ground state. Atoms at this state possess some residual energy, or zero-point energy, marking a macroscopic phase transition much like a fourth state of matter in its own right. 

Such were the changing times that Bose’s work received much attention gradually. To Bose himself, he was fine without a Nobel, saying, “I have got all the recognition I deserve”. A modest character and gentleman, he resonates a lot with the mental image of a scientist who’s a servant to the scientific discipline itself.

But what’s more upsetting is that, Bose is still a bit of a stranger in India, where he was born and lived. He studied physics at the Presidency College, Calcutta under the tutelage that saw other great Indian physicists, including Jagdish Chandra Bose and Meghnad Saha. He was awarded the Padma Vibhushan, the highest civilian award by the Government of India in 1954. Institutes have been named in his honour, but despite this, his reputation has little if no mention at all in public discourse. 

To his physicists’ peers in his generation and beyond, he was recognized in scientific lexicology. Paul Dirac, the British physicist coined the name ‘bosons’ in Bose’s honor (‘bose-on’). These refer to quantum particles including photons and others with integer quantum spins, a formulation that arose only because of Bose’s invention of quantum statistics. In fact, the media popular, ‘god particle’, the Higgs boson, carries a bit of Bose as much as it does of Peter Higgs who shared the 2013 Nobel Prize in Physics with Francois Englert for producing the hypothesis. 

There are plenty of scientists across the world from history, across the colonial era and beyond – which this ‘Know the Scientist’ page seeks to shed light on. It’s through us retelling these stories time and again do their experiences become immortalized in time for us to understand. 

Space & Physics

Magnetic Fields Found to Shape Star Formation Near Milky Way Disc

Scientists map magnetic fields in molecular clouds near the Milky Way, revealing their key role in slowing and shaping star formation.

Published

on

Magnetic fields star formation in molecular clouds within a nebula in the Milky Way
Image credit: NASA/Unsplash

Scientists map magnetic fields in molecular clouds near the Milky Way, revealing their key role in slowing and shaping star formation.

Scientists have uncovered new insights into how stars are formed by mapping the magnetic fields surrounding molecular clouds near the Milky Way’s disc, offering a deeper understanding of one of the universe’s most fundamental processes.

The study focuses on two small molecular clouds—L1604 and L121—revealing how magnetic fields influence the balance between gravity and internal pressure during star formation.

Magnetic Fields Star Formation in Milky Way Clouds

For decades, astronomers have understood star formation as a balance between gravity pulling gas inward and internal pressure pushing outward. However, the new research highlights a third critical factor: magnetic fields.

In a media statement, the researchers explained that magnetic fields act as an invisible force shaping how molecular clouds evolve and collapse to form stars.

The study was conducted by scientists from the Aryabhatta Research Institute of Observational Sciences (ARIES)m Uttarakhand, India and Assam University, using advanced polarimetric techniques to detect otherwise invisible magnetic structures.

Magnetic Fields Star Formation Observed Using Polarimetry

To map these fields, the team used R-band polarimetry with the ARIES Imaging Polarimeter mounted on a 104-cm telescope in Nainital.

This technique measures how starlight becomes polarised as it passes through dust grains aligned by magnetic fields.

In a media statement, the researchers said that by analysing thousands of such light signals, they were able to “see” the skeleton of magnetic fields surrounding the molecular clouds for the first time.

Two Molecular Clouds Reveal Contrasting Behaviour

The study examined two distinct clouds:

  • L1604, located about 816 parsecs away, is dense and massive, with strong potential for future star formation
  • L121, much closer at 124 parsecs, is less dense but exhibits a stronger and more organised magnetic field

In a media statement, the scientists noted that the orderly magnetic structure in L121 suggests it has not yet undergone intense gravitational collapse, unlike more active star-forming regions.

Magnetic Fields Star Formation Controlled by Energy Balance

By calculating magnetic field strength, the researchers found that both clouds are sub-critical, meaning magnetic forces are strong enough to resist gravitational collapse across most of their structure.

In a media statement, the team stated that magnetic energy dominates over both turbulence and gravity at the outer regions of the clouds.

However, deep within the dense cores, gravity may begin to take over, creating conditions suitable for star formation.

The “Recipe” for Star Formation

The findings suggest that magnetic fields play a crucial role in regulating how quickly stars form.

In a media statement, researchers said that magnetism acts as an “invisible hand,” slowing down star formation and preventing galaxies from converting all their gas into stars at once.

The study positions L1604 and L121 as natural laboratories for understanding the interplay between gravity and magnetism.

Rather than being passive clouds, they represent dynamic systems where fundamental forces interact over millions of years to shape the birth of stars.

The findings offer a clearer picture of how galaxies like the Milky Way sustain star formation over long cosmic timescales, balancing collapse with control.

Continue Reading

Space & Physics

Researchers Use AI to Enable Robots to ‘See’ Through Walls

MIT researchers develop AI-powered system using wireless signals to help robots see through walls and reconstruct hidden objects and indoor spaces.

Published

on

MIT researchers use generative AI to reconstruct hidden 3D objects.
MIT researchers use generative AI to reconstruct hidden 3D objects. Credit: Courtesy of the researchers/MIT News

Researchers at Massachusetts Institute of Technology have developed a new artificial intelligence-powered system that allows robots to detect and reconstruct objects hidden behind walls and obstacles, marking a significant breakthrough in machine perception.

The system combines wireless signals with generative AI models to enable what researchers describe as a new form of “wireless vision,” potentially transforming robotics, logistics, and smart environments.

AI See Through Walls Using Wireless Signals

The research builds on over a decade of work using millimeter wave (mmWave) signals—similar to those used in Wi-Fi—which can pass through materials such as drywall, plastic, and cardboard and reflect off hidden objects.

Earlier approaches could only capture partial shapes due to limitations in how these signals reflect.

The new system overcomes this by combining wireless reflections with generative AI, enabling the reconstruction of complete object shapes even when they are not directly visible.

“What we’ve done now is develop generative AI models that help us understand wireless reflections. This opens up a lot of interesting new applications, but technically it is also a qualitative leap in capabilities, from being able to fill in gaps we were not able to see before to being able to interpret reflections and reconstruct entire scenes,” said Fadel Adib, in a media statement.

“We are using AI to finally unlock wireless vision.”

AI See Through Walls Improves Object Reconstruction

The system, called Wave-Former, first creates a partial image of a hidden object using reflected wireless signals. It then uses a trained AI model to fill in missing parts and refine the reconstruction.

In tests, Wave-Former successfully reconstructed around 70 everyday objects—including boxes, utensils, and fruits—with nearly 20% higher accuracy than existing methods.

The objects were placed behind or under materials such as wood, fabric, and plastic, demonstrating the system’s robustness in real-world conditions.

AI See Through Walls Reconstructs Entire Rooms

Beyond individual objects, the researchers developed a second system capable of reconstructing entire indoor environments.

Using a single stationary radar, the system tracks how wireless signals bounce off moving humans and surrounding objects. These reflections—often considered noise—are analysed by AI to map out the room layout.

The system, known as RISE, was tested using over 100 human movement patterns and achieved twice the accuracy of existing techniques in reconstructing indoor spaces.

Privacy-Preserving Alternative to Cameras

Unlike camera-based systems, this approach does not capture visual images, offering a privacy-preserving alternative for indoor monitoring and robotics.

Because it relies on wireless signals rather than cameras, it can detect presence and layout without revealing identifiable details.

Applications in Warehousing and Smart Homes

The researchers say the technology could have wide-ranging applications:

  • Warehouses: Robots could verify packed items before shipping, reducing errors and returns
  • Smart homes: Robots could better understand human location and movement
  • Human-robot interaction: Improved safety and efficiency in shared environments

The system could also pave the way for future “foundation models” trained specifically on wireless data, similar to how large AI models are trained for language and vision.

Continue Reading

Health

Researchers Develop AI Method That Makes Computer Vision Models More Explainable

A new technique developed by MIT researchers could help make artificial intelligence systems more accurate and transparent in high-stakes fields such as health care and autonomous driving by improving how computer vision models explain their decisions.

Published

on

MIT researchers have developed a new explainable AI method that improves the accuracy and transparency of computer vision models, helping users trust AI predictions in healthcare and autonomous driving.
Image credit: Tara/Pexels

MIT researchers have developed a new explainable AI method that improves the accuracy and transparency of computer vision models, helping users trust AI predictions in healthcare and autonomous driving.

Researchers at MIT have developed a new approach to make computer vision models more transparent, offering a potential boost to trust and accountability in safety-critical applications such as medical diagnosis and autonomous driving.

In a media statement, the researchers said the method improves on a widely used explainability technique known as concept bottleneck modeling, which enables AI systems to show the human-understandable concepts behind a prediction. The new approach is designed to produce clearer explanations while also improving prediction accuracy.

Why explainable AI matters

In areas such as health care, users often need more than just a model’s output. They want to understand why a system arrived at a particular conclusion before deciding whether to rely on it. Concept bottleneck models attempt to address that need by forcing an AI system to make predictions through a set of intermediate concepts that humans can interpret.

For example, when analysing a medical image for melanoma, a clinician might define concepts such as “clustered brown dots” or “variegated pigmentation.” The model would first identify those concepts and then use them to arrive at its final prediction.

But the researchers said pre-defined concepts can sometimes be too broad, irrelevant or incomplete for a specific task, limiting both the quality of explanations and the model’s performance. To overcome that, the MIT team developed a method that extracts concepts the model has already learned during training and then compels it to use those concepts when making decisions.

The approach relies on two specialised machine-learning models. One extracts the most relevant internal features learned by the target model, while the other translates them into plain-language concepts that humans can understand. This makes it possible to convert a pretrained computer vision model into one capable of explaining its reasoning through interpretable concepts.

“In a sense, we want to be able to read the minds of these computer vision models. A concept bottleneck model is one way for users to tell what the model is thinking and why it made a certain prediction. Because our method uses better concepts, it can lead to higher accuracy and ultimately improve the accountability of black-box AI models,” Antonio De Santis, lead author of the study, said in a media statement.

De Santis is a graduate student at Polytechnic University of Milan and carried out the research while serving as a visiting graduate student at MIT’s Computer Science and Artificial Intelligence Laboratory (CSAIL). The paper was co-authored by Schrasing Tong, Marco Brambilla of Polytechnic University of Milan, and Lalana Kagal of CSAIL. The research will be presented at the International Conference on Learning Representations.

Concept bottleneck models have gained attention as a way to improve AI explainability by introducing an intermediate reasoning step between an input image and the final output. In one example, a bird-classification model might identify concepts such as “yellow legs” and “blue wings” before predicting a barn swallow.

However, the researchers noted that these concepts are often generated in advance by humans or large language models, which may not always match the needs of the task. Even when a model is given a fixed concept set, it can still rely on hidden information not visible to users, a challenge known as information leakage.

“These models are trained to maximize performance, so the model might secretly use concepts we are unaware of,” De Santis said in a media statement.

The team’s solution was to tap into the knowledge the model had already acquired from large volumes of training data. Using a sparse autoencoder, the method isolates the most relevant learned features and reconstructs them into a small number of concepts. A multimodal large language model then describes each concept in simple language and labels the training images by marking which concepts are present or absent.

The annotated dataset is then used to train a concept bottleneck module, which is inserted into the target model. This forces the model to make predictions using only the extracted concepts.

The researchers said one of the biggest challenges was ensuring that the automatically identified concepts were both accurate and understandable to humans. To reduce the risk of hidden reasoning, the model is limited to just five concepts for each prediction, encouraging it to focus only on the most relevant information and making the explanation easier to follow.

When tested against state-of-the-art concept bottleneck models on tasks including bird species classification and skin lesion identification, the new method delivered the highest accuracy while also producing more precise explanations, according to the researchers. It also generated concepts that were more relevant to the images in the dataset.

Still, the team acknowledged that the broader challenge of balancing accuracy and interpretability remains unresolved.

“We’ve shown that extracting concepts from the original model can outperform other CBMs, but there is still a tradeoff between interpretability and accuracy that needs to be addressed. Black-box models that are not interpretable still outperform ours,” De Santis said in a media statement.

Looking ahead, the researchers plan to explore ways to further reduce information leakage, possibly by adding additional concept bottleneck modules. They also aim to scale up the method by using a larger multimodal language model to annotate a larger training dataset, which could improve performance further.

This latest work adds to growing efforts to make AI systems not only more powerful, but also more understandable in domains where trust can be as important as accuracy.

Continue Reading

Trending