Connect with us

The Sciences

Challenging the Myth: Trees Are Not the Ultimate Solution for Overheating Cities

The cooling effects of trees are complex and vary significantly depending on the context in which they are planted, says researchers

Published

on

Image credit: Pixabay

A new study led by the University of Cambridge offers fresh insights into how urban tree canopies, while effective at cooling cities during the day, may inadvertently trap heat at night.

As global temperatures continue to rise, many cities are grappling with the effects of urban heat stress, which is linked to increased illness, energy consumption, and social inequality. Excessive heat can also damage urban infrastructure, highlighting the urgent need for effective mitigation strategies. Among these, tree planting has become a central component of efforts to cool down cities.

However, a recent study led by the University of Cambridge warns that not all tree species or planting methods are equally effective in reducing urban temperatures. According to Dr. Ronita Bardhan, Associate Professor of Sustainable Built Environment at the University of Cambridge’s Department of Architecture, “Trees have a crucial role to play in cooling cities down but we need to plant them much more strategically to maximize the benefits they can provide.”

New Insights on Tree Cooling and Heating Effects

Published in Communications Earth & Environment, the study offers the first comprehensive global assessment of urban tree cooling. By analyzing 182 studies from 110 cities worldwide, the research reveals how tree planting can lower pedestrian-level air temperatures by up to 12°C, with 83% of cities studied achieving temperatures below the “thermal comfort threshold” of 26°C. However, the study also shows that the cooling effects of trees can vary dramatically depending on species, climate, and urban design.

Dr. Bardhan noted, “Our study busts the myth that trees are the ultimate panacea for overheating cities across the globe. The cooling effects of trees are complex and vary significantly depending on the context in which they are planted.”

Cooling Benefits Vary by Climate Type

The study found that urban trees tend to be more effective in cooling cities in hot, dry climates compared to those in humid, tropical areas. In hot and dry climates like Nigeria’s savanna, trees can lower city temperatures by as much as 12°C during the day, but can also increase nighttime temperatures by up to 0.8°C. In arid climates, trees were shown to cool cities by just over 9°C but also raise nighttime temperatures by 0.4°C. Conversely, in tropical rainforest climates, daytime cooling was limited to about 2°C, with nighttime warming reaching 0.8°C.

“Trees perform best in dry, hot climates, but in tropical regions with high humidity, their nighttime warming effect can negate their daytime cooling benefits,” said Dr. Bardhan.

Strategic Tree Planting: The Key to Maximizing Cooling

The study underscores the importance of planting trees in a way that aligns with a city’s specific urban form and climate conditions. Cities with open layouts, for instance, benefit from a mix of evergreen and deciduous trees of varying sizes, leading to more effective cooling across different seasons. In contrast, compact urban layouts, like those in Cairo or Dubai, favor evergreen species that are better suited to dry, hot conditions.

The researchers found that mixed-species planting could provide up to 0.5°C more cooling than monoculture tree planting, as different trees offer varying levels of shade and sunlight penetration at different heights. Furthermore, larger green spaces allow for bigger tree canopies, leading to better overall cooling in dry climates.

“Our study provides context-specific greening guidelines for urban planners to more effectively harness tree cooling in the face of global warming,” Dr. Bardhan said. “Urban planners need to plant the right mix of trees in optimal positions to maximize cooling benefits.”

Looking to the Future: Planning for Warmer Climates

The study also stresses that as climate change progresses, it is essential for cities to choose resilient tree species that will continue to thrive under hotter conditions. “Urban planners should plan for future warmer climates by choosing resilient species which will continue to thrive and maintain cooling benefits,” Dr. Bardhan emphasized.

Furthermore, the researchers note that trees alone cannot solve the issue of urban heat. To complement tree planting, solutions like solar shading and reflective materials should continue to play a vital role in mitigating the heat effects in cities.

A Tool for Urban Planners

In an effort to make these findings more accessible, the researchers have developed an interactive database and map that allows users to estimate the cooling efficacy of different tree planting strategies based on the climate and urban characteristics of cities worldwide. This tool will help urban planners design more effective, climate-specific tree planting schemes.

Earth

Meltwater ponds might have sheltered life during earth’s deep freeze

During this time, the planet was believed to be encased in ice, with global temperatures plummeting to as low as -50°C

Published

on

Researchers Ian Hawes (University of Waikato) and Marc Schallenberg (University of Otago) assess the physical and chemical properties of a meltwater pond. Credit: Roger Summons

In a study published in Nature Communications, scientists from MIT have proposed that shallow meltwater ponds may have provided critical refuges for early complex life during one of Earth’s most extreme ice ages — the “Snowball Earth” period, which occurred between 635 and 720 million years ago.

During this time, the planet was believed to be encased in ice, with global temperatures plummeting to as low as -50°C. Despite the harsh conditions, complex cellular life — known as eukaryotes — managed to survive. The new research suggests that these life forms could have found sanctuary in small, briny pools formed on the surface of equatorial ice sheets.

“Meltwater ponds are valid candidates for where early eukaryotes could have sheltered during these planet-wide glaciation events,” said lead author Fatima Husain, a graduate researcher in MIT’s Department of Earth, Atmospheric and Planetary Sciences, in a media statement. “This shows us that diversity is present and possible in these sorts of settings. It’s really a story of life’s resilience.”

The team drew parallels between ancient equatorial ice sheets and modern Antarctic conditions. They studied contemporary meltwater ponds on Antarctica’s McMurdo Ice Shelf — an area first dubbed “dirty ice” by explorers in the early 20th century. These ponds, formed by sun-warmed dark debris trapped within surface ice, provided a modern analog to the possible melt environments of the Cryogenian Period.

Samples taken from these Antarctic ponds revealed clear signatures of eukaryotic life. Using chemical and genetic analysis, including the identification of sterols and ribosomal RNA, the researchers detected algae, protists, and microscopic animals — all descendants of early eukaryotes. Each pond supported unique communities, with differences shaped largely by salinity levels.

“No two ponds were alike,” Husain noted. “There are repeating casts of characters, but they’re present in different abundances. We found diverse assemblages of eukaryotes from all the major groups in all the ponds studied.”

These findings suggest that meltwater ponds — overlooked in previous hypotheses — could have served as vital “above-ice oases” for survival and even diversification during Snowball Earth.

“There are many hypotheses for where life could have survived and sheltered during the Cryogenian, but we don’t have excellent analogs for all of them,” Husain explained. “Above-ice meltwater ponds occur on Earth today and are accessible, giving us the opportunity to really focus in on the eukaryotes which live in these environments.”

The study was co-authored by MIT’s Roger Summons, Thomas Evans (formerly MIT), Jasmin Millar of Cardiff University, Anne Jungblut of the Natural History Museum in London, and Ian Hawes of the University of Waikato in New Zealand.

By uncovering how life may have persisted through Earth’s frozen past, the research not only deepens understanding of our planet’s history — it may also help inform the search for life on icy worlds beyond Earth.

Continue Reading

Society

How India’s Richest Man Remembers This Chemical Engineer

Here are the four key insights Mukesh Ambani shared about renowned chemical engineer Prof. M M Sharma:

Published

on

Image credit: By special arrangement

At the launch of the biography Divine Scientist chronicling the life of legendary Indian chemical engineer Prof. Man Mohan Sharma, Mukesh Ambani, CMD of Reliance Industries, offered a moving tribute that captured the intellect, values, and national impact of his former teacher.

Prof. Sharma is a renowned chemical engineer, who became the first Indian engineer to be elected as a Fellow of Royal Society, the UK in 1990.

Here are the four key insights Ambani shared about Prof. Sharma:

1. The Alchemist of Minds

Ambani recalled how Prof. Sharma transformed his understanding of chemical engineering — and leadership. “He had the power to convert curiosity into knowledge, knowledge into commercial value, and both into everlasting wisdom,” he said. Choosing ICT over IIT Bombay, Ambani said Sharma’s first lecture confirmed he’d made the right decision.

2. Master of ‘Economics of Chemistry’

“He wasn’t just a scientist — he taught us how molecules make money,” said Ambani. He fondly remembered calling Sharma a “Bania chemical engineering professor” for blending scientific brilliance with business sense — a philosophy that informed Reliance’s rise in the petrochemicals industry.

3. Sustainability Visionary

Long before sustainability became a buzzword, Prof. Sharma taught his students to turn every ‘by-product’ into a ‘co-product’. “He insisted nothing should be wasted,” said Ambani. That vision shaped Reliance’s integrated manufacturing strategy, from crude oil to consumer products.

4. A Silent Architect of Economic Reforms

Prof. Sharma wasn’t just a scholar — he was a behind-the-scenes changemaker. Ambani revealed how Sharma, alongside his father Dhirubhai Ambani, lobbied for deregulating India’s chemical industry. “He told policymakers: if you want India to grow, end the license raj and build scale,” said Ambani. “He is not just our Guru — he is a Rashtra Guru.”

The emotional address underscored the enduring influence of a teacher whose lessons extend far beyond the classroom — into boardrooms, factories, and the future of India.

Continue Reading

Earth

How Tuna and Swordfish Hunt in the Deep; MIT Oceanographers find the answer

A new study reveals that tuna and swordfish are making regular, long-distance plunges into the twilight zone, a mysterious and dark layer of the ocean, to fill their stomachs

Published

on

Image credit: Pixabay

Imagine diving into the ocean’s depths, descending further than the eye can see, into a cold, almost completely dark world where every movement feels like a gamble. For some of the ocean’s most formidable predators—like tuna and swordfish—this is no mere adventure; it’s a necessity. A new study reveals that these apex hunters are making regular, long-distance plunges into the twilight zone, a mysterious and dark layer of the ocean, to fill their stomachs. And what they’re finding there could change the way we think about ocean ecosystems and the future of commercial fishing.

For decades, oceanographers knew that large fish like tuna and swordfish occasionally ventured into the depths of the ocean, but the purpose of these dives remained unclear. Were these predators hunting for food, or were they just exploring? A recent breakthrough by MIT oceanographers has answered that question—and the results are more astonishing than anyone could have imagined.

Ciara Willis, foreground, and co-author Kayla Gardner pose with MOCNESS, a series of big nets that are used to target different ocean depths. Credits: Courtesy of Ciara Willis

In a pioneering study published in ICES Journal of Marine Science, an MIT team led by Ciara Willis has found that these fish are relying heavily on the twilight zone, a dark, cold layer between 200 and 1,000 meters below the surface, for as much as 60% of their diet. This discovery reveals a much deeper connection to this enigmatic zone than scientists previously realized.

“We’ve known for a long time that these fish and many other predators feed on twilight zone prey,” says Willis, a postdoc at the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution, in a press statement. “But the extent to which they rely on this deep-sea food web for their diet has been unclear.”

The Hidden Feast

The twilight zone—often overlooked in marine research—has been gaining attention for its rich ecosystem. It’s a vast, underexplored region teeming with strange creatures, from tiny lanternfish to massive squid, all adapted to live without sunlight. While the surface waters are teeming with life, they offer less concentrated food for large predators. By contrast, the twilight zone is like a dense buffet, providing predators like bigeye tuna, yellowfin tuna, and swordfish a more reliable food source.

“This is a really understudied region of the ocean, and it’s filled with all these fantastic, weird animals,” Willis says. “We call it the ‘deep ocean buffet.’”

The deep sea creatures in the twilight zone have evolved to migrate vertically—swimming to the surface to feed at night and returning to the depths by day to avoid predators. For the big predators of the open ocean, this behavior creates a prime opportunity to feast. Bigeye tuna, yellowfin tuna, and swordfish dive regularly into these depths to hunt. But until recently, scientists didn’t know just how important this food source truly was.

“We saw the bigeye tuna were far and away the most consistent in where they got their food from,” Willis explains. “The swordfish and yellowfin tuna were more variable, meaning that if large-scale fishing were to target the twilight zone, bigeye tuna might be the ones most at risk.”

The Price of Overfishing the Deep

This discovery comes at a critical time. The growing interest in commercial fishing in the twilight zone, despite its often unpalatable fish species, has raised alarms. These creatures are increasingly being harvested for fishmeal and fish oil, products commonly used in animal feed and other industries. However, as researchers point out, this could have dire consequences for tuna and swordfish populations.

“There is increasing interest in commercial fishing in the ocean’s twilight zone,” says Willis. “If we start heavily fishing that layer of the ocean, our study suggests that could have profound implications for tuna and swordfish, which are highly reliant on this region.”

The team’s findings underscore the need for careful management of the twilight zone’s resources. Given that tuna and swordfish rely on this zone for up to 60% of their food, disruptions to the ecosystem here could have cascading effects on the open ocean and the global fishing industry.

“Predatory fish like tunas have a 50% reliance on twilight zone food webs,” Willis warns. “If we start heavily fishing in that region, it could lead to uncertainty around the profitability of tuna fisheries.”

As the twilight zone becomes a target for increasing commercial interest, scientists are calling for greater caution in how we approach the deep ocean’s complex food web. What lies in the shadows of the ocean’s depths may be far more crucial to our marine ecosystems than anyone has realized.

Continue Reading

Trending