Society
SpaceX prepares for the Great Filter – but why?
What’s Elon Musk’s gameplan to get humans to thrive in the universe all about?

Two weeks ago, Ed Publica did a news story on Elon Musk’s tweet.
It sure was a headline topic in itself.
“We are mapping out a game plan to get a million people to Mars,” posted Musk. “Civilization only passes the single-planet Great Filter when Mars can survive even if Earth supply ships stop coming.”
Press releases that came in the wake of the tweet, never did engage with Musk’s invocation of – the Great Filter.
The Great Filter is what the astronomer Seth Shostak stated, a ‘variant on the Fermi paradox’.
The Fermi paradox was borne out of an idea proposed by the enigmatic 20th century theoretical physicist, Enrico Fermi, who posed a profound, philosophical question.
If an intelligent civilization were capable of space travel, and extraterrestrial life existed, then where are they?
In fact, the question itself was a paradoxical idea. Either of course, aliens don’t exist – or if they do, then they’re hiding in plain sight, not wanting to be contacted. Perhaps in the latter case, aliens want to avoid being colonized or wiped extinct by a civilization with superior technology. No one knows what the answer is. We don’t know yet if it even is a paradox with an answer.
But the Great Filter theory, proposed by an economist, Robin Hanson in 1998 makes an interesting argument that offers a possible resolution against the Fermi paradox. Maybe life is uncommon, or can easily go extinct. There can be some factors at play to stop a civilization from thriving and spawn a population to safeguard it.
Maybe humanity’s destined to live, and then die on earth – only to live on Mars, until every resource exhausts and human genes are ferried to distant exoplanets to hopefully spawn and recreate humanity there. Or perhaps humanity’s alone amongst the trillions of stars in the universe, because someone has to make the first step to show how difficult it is for life to thrive.

Credit: Greg Rakozy / Unsplash
How feasible is this?
Musk’s prophetic vision is more his vision for humanity – reminiscent in science fiction novels and films.
There’s a line from the movie Interstellar (2014), when Michael Caine, playing an astrophysicist, says, ‘We’re not meant to save the world, we’re meant to leave it.’ In the movie, earth gets plagued by crop blight, and people starve to death when food resources are hard to sustain. Although the problem was foreseeable, we were too late to act on it. And that was the main driver of the plot. Astronauts were dispatched into a wormhole and tunnel through into a different galaxy light years away. Humanity was doomed, and so the astronauts prepared human embryos to take our place and be the Adam and Eves of their species.
The Great Filter and the Fermi paradox are at best a useful thinking exercise about the myriad ways human imagination really works.
Musk’s idea to colonize Mars makes some sense in that it’s about taking a small step to demonstrate we can demonstrate a necessary first step of survival.
But then space is cruel and indifferent. The Martian atmosphere is completely thin, with almost zero atmospheric pressure. It’s not even about the carbon dioxide in what’s left in that atmosphere – there’s just barely any atmosphere there. Musk probably is aware of this, given he has a physics background!
For instance, how do we pressurize a whole planet? The optimism is that technology can circumvent these problems.
This technology, possibly in a few decades, can seem like ‘magic’ to us. The Great Filter and the Fermi paradox are at best a useful thinking exercise about the myriad ways human imagination really works.
And until we demonstrate basic physics that works in its favor, aren’t these just wishful fantasies?
For instance, how can SpaceX ‘gameplan’ Mars’ colonization, if the company doesn’t itself survive the Great Filter test? Who else in the world is taking this seriously apart from Elon Musk?
‘Colonizing’ space
Musk’s gameplan invites more questions, since there’s barely any discussion that he leads on it.
Musk is polarizing to his critics, who question the need for expensive space exploration programs that have no direct benefit on our economy.
Musk’s usage of the term ‘colonization’ can be seen to resonate with the sentiment in the 15th century when the West discovered the rest of the world through the sea-route. However, it didn’t fare well for the rest of the world. One notable example is when Christopher Columbus, ‘discovered’ North America, when he was in search of India – he and his men began the subjugation of Native Americans.

An 1850 painting depicting Christopher Columbus (center) surrounded by people, before embarking a ship in August 1492. Credit: Wellcome Trust
Meanwhile, the Portuguese voyager Vasco da Gama arrived at the shores of India, in Kozhikode. That opened up routes for vessels of the East India Company from across Europe to trade – and then colonize Indians.
I’m not suggesting Musk has nefarious plans at play. However, what’s the chance that future government policies somehow get blindsided, or ignorant of advice from experts outside science on the political implications of space exploration?
And what better ‘gameplan’ can there really be if it starts with experts from a diversity of fields huddling together for an enlightening discussion?
Society
Starliner crew challenge rhetoric, says they were never “stranded”
Sunita Williams and Barry Wilmore don’t require a “rescue mission.” The veteran astronauts challenged some misconceptions the public has had about their over-extended stay aboard the International Space Station (ISS), following the Boeing Starliner mishap last June.

Last year on June 5th, NASA astronauts Sunita Williams and Barry Wilmore were on a flight testing mission to dock a Boeing Starliner spaceraft to the International Space Station (ISS). Set to return just eight-days later, their mission met with an ill-fated death. A few thrusters failed, in addition to a helium leak onboard, rendered the Boeing Starliner spacecraft too unsafe for NASA’s liking. The agency’s stubborn refusal to let their astronauts be under harm’s way, meant the Starliner returned to earth later in September without its crew.
In the months passing since then, Williams and Wilmore never left the public gaze. Media headlines and TV news anchors have taken to report the event as a major predicament. This is despite the fact, that the astronauts were neither stranded, nor left alone. Williams and Wilmore weigh in on the issue recently during a live interaction with the media.
“Butch (Barry Wilmore) and I knew this was a test flight,” Sunita Williams said to CBS News. “We knew that we would probably find some things (wrong with Starliner) and we found some stuff, and so that was not a surprise.”
Musk made a statement there that sparked controversy. “They were left up there for political reasons.”
This is not to say the situation the duo found themselves in is unprecedented; for it is indeed unprecedented. When NASA had Boeing Starliner‘s software reconfigured and return to earth in one shape. NASA had the benefit of doubt, given their original assessment was made with the best possible evidence available at the time; and not to compromise upon crew safety. As of latest plans, Williams and Wilmore will return to earth by late-March 2025 at the earliest.
But the rhetoric has reinforced calls to put together a “rescue mission.” SpaceX CEO Elon Musk, who advises incumbent US President Donald Trump, claimed at a Fox News interview that his proposal to bring the astronauts back in September was rejected by the previous administration led by President Joe Biden. Musk made a statement there that sparked controversy. “They were left up there for political reasons.”
Narratives draw ire from the space community
Musk’s comments drew ire from other veteran astronauts. Andreas Mogensen, a former ISS commander during Expedition 70, reacted to Musk’s comment on X to say, “What a lie. And from someone who complains about lack of honesty from the mainstream media.” Musk responded in kind soon there after, aggressively standing his ground. However, the astronauts themselves found the claims unsubstantiated.
According to WCVB Boston, Barry Wilmore himself said, “I have not heard that … I’m not sure that could be the case based on what I know. We came up here with a plan to return, and the plan changed.” NASA themselves had issued a clarification in the aftermath of Musk’s own comments, claiming it had never received a direct proposal from SpaceX for any mission. Nor did they warrant such a “rescue mission”, as now President Trump has called on for.
Political considerations are not a factor in changing the timelines in the ISS expeditions. “The White House was very good about letting us make safety decisions and leaving that to the experts at NASA,” Bloomberg reported Pam Melroy, an ex-NASA administrator involved in the mission, as having said.

Long-exposure photograph taken on July 3, 2024, of the Boeing Starliner docked to the ISS, with the earth in the background | Credit: Matthew Dominick/NASA
“Help us change the rhetoric …”
Risks and derailed plans are part and parcel of space travel, and something space agencies draw backup plans for. Much of the public angst and concern for the astronauts is the loneliness arising from prolonged isolation in space, and fears of mishap with the ISS.
“That is what the human space flight program is; it prepares for any and all contingencies that we can conceive of, and we prepare for those,” Newsweek reports Sunita Williams as having said. Health professionals on ground have helped monitor and manage their physical and psychological fitness. Inadvertently, they contribute to research studying the human body’s ability to adapt in the micro-gravity conditions; as well as psychological resilience and the astronauts’ ability to handle stress. But this is nothing astronauts cannot handle. In fact, Williams compared her situation with that of a tourist. “I call it a little vacation from earth.”
“So if you’ll help us change the rhetoric, help us change the narrative…let’s change it to ‘prepared and committed’ rather than what you’ve been hearing,” WCVB Boston reported Williams as having said.
They have had astronauts from the Crew 8 expedition give them company during the arrival in June, assisting them with their microgravity-based scientific experiments. In September, they were joined by a new party of astronauts of the Crew 9 mission – Roscosmos’ Alexander Gubnov, and NASA’s Nick Hague – replacing the astronauts from Crew 8.
In addition to extra clothing and stockpile of food, NASA had left two extra seats were left empty for Williams and Wilmore to return along with Gubnov and Hague on their return later this March or April, when astronauts from upcoming Crew 10 dock later this month. Given there is a spacecraft docked to the ISS at all time, they have all what it takes to evacuate during an emergency.
“So if you’ll help us change the rhetoric, help us change the narrative…let’s change it to ‘prepared and committed’ rather than what you’ve been hearing,” WCVB Boston reported Williams as having said.
Health
Imagine if your clothing could monitor and protect your health
Researchers Develop Programmable “Fiber Computer” for Health Monitoring in Clothing

Researchers at MIT have unveiled an autonomous, programmable computer integrated into elastic fibers that can monitor health conditions and physical activity, offering real-time alerts for potential health risks. The fiber, which is nearly invisible to the wearer, is comfortable, machine washable, and can be embedded in clothing such as shirts or leggings.
Unlike traditional “wearables” that monitor health from a single location, such as the wrist or chest, this fiber-based technology offers a unique advantage. It is woven into fabrics, allowing it to stay in contact with large areas of the body, including those close to vital organs, thus enabling a more comprehensive understanding of human physiology.
The fiber computer incorporates a range of microdevices—sensors, microcontrollers, memory, Bluetooth modules, optical communication, and a battery—into a single elastic fiber. MIT researchers attached four fiber computers to a top and a pair of leggings, with each fiber running along a limb. These computers were programmed to use machine learning to autonomously recognize different exercises, achieving an average accuracy rate of about 70%. Remarkably, when the individual fibers communicated with each other, their collective accuracy increased to nearly 95%.
Yoel Fink, Professor of Materials Science and Engineering at MIT and senior author of the study, shared his vision for the future of this technology: “Our bodies broadcast gigabytes of data through the skin every second in the form of heat, sound, biochemicals, electrical potentials, and light, all of which carry information about our activities, emotions, and health. Unfortunately, most if not all of it gets absorbed and then lost in the clothes we wear. Wouldn’t it be great if we could teach clothes to capture, analyze, store, and communicate this important information in the form of valuable health and activity insights?”
In a real-world test, U.S. Army and Navy service members will wear fiber-computer-equipped base layer shirts during a month-long winter mission to the Arctic. The mission, dubbed Musk Ox II, will cover 1,000 kilometers in temperatures averaging -40°F. These fiber computers will provide valuable health data, helping to ensure the safety of participants in extreme conditions.
“In the not-too-distant future, fiber computers will allow us to run apps and get valuable health care and safety services from simple everyday apparel,” said Fink. “We are excited to see glimpses of this future in the upcoming Arctic mission through our partners in the U.S. Army, Navy, and DARPA.”
This research builds upon more than a decade of work at MIT’s Fibers@MIT lab and was supported by various military and academic institutions. The breakthrough comes from overcoming a major engineering challenge: integrating complex microdevices into a fiber that retains flexibility and durability. The researchers achieved this by using a flexible circuit board design and an advanced thermoplastic elastomer that allows the fibers to stretch more than 60% without breaking.
The fiber computers, which can communicate via Bluetooth to a smartphone or other devices, enable the creation of a textile network within garments. When multiple fibers are embedded in a garment, they form a network that shares data and enhances functionality, as seen in their exercise-recognition model. This breakthrough could revolutionize health monitoring and injury prevention.
As the team looks ahead, their next steps include enhancing the interposer technique to incorporate additional microelectronic devices. The team is also preparing for the Arctic mission, where the fibers will be used to monitor the physiological effects of extreme cold on the human body.
U.S. Army Major Hefner, who will lead the Musk Ox II mission, highlighted the potential of this technology: “One of my main concerns is how to keep my team safe from debilitating cold weather injuries—something conventional systems just don’t provide. These computing fabrics will help us understand the body’s response to extreme cold and ultimately predict and prevent injury.”
Karl Friedl, Senior Research Scientist at the U.S. Army, emphasized the transformative potential of the technology: “Imagine near-term fiber computers in fabrics and apparel that sense and respond to the environment and to the physiological status of the individual, increasing comfort and performance while providing real-time health monitoring and protection.”
Health
IITK Researchers Unveils Key Receptor Structure for Cancer and Respiratory Treatments
The team successfully visualized the atomic structure of CXCR2, a crucial human receptor involved in the progression of cancer and respiratory diseases

Researchers from the Department of Biological Sciences and Bioengineering at the Indian Institute of Technology (IIT) Kanpur have made a path breaking discovery that could pave the way for new treatments for cancer and respiratory diseases. The team successfully visualized the atomic structure of CXCR2, a crucial human receptor involved in the progression of these diseases. Their findings, published in the prestigious journal Molecular Cell, offer a new perspective on targeting this receptor for therapeutic intervention.
CXCR2 is a key receptor in the immune system, involved in directing immune cells to infection and injury sites through interaction with chemokines—small signaling proteins. CXCR2’s role in inflammatory disorders and cancers such as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), asthma, atherosclerosis, and pancreatic cancer makes it a promising target for new drugs.
Using advanced cryogenic-electron microscopy (cryo-EM), the IIT Kanpur researchers captured unprecedented details of the receptor’s “lock-and-key” mechanism, shedding light on how CXCR2 interacts with multiple chemokines. This discovery addresses a fundamental question in biomedical science about how a single receptor can bind to various chemokines and trigger biological responses. The visualization also opens up opportunities for designing novel therapeutics.
“Our findings provide a molecular blueprint for designing next-generation therapeutics that can precisely target CXCR2 and potentially reduce its role in cancer and respiratory diseases. By visualizing this receptor in its active state, we now have the opportunity to develop highly specific inhibitors that can disrupt its function, potentially leading to significant advancements in treatment strategies,” said Professor Arun Kumar Shukla, the lead investigator of the study at IIT Kanpur.
The research team at IIT Kanpur includes Shirsha Saha, Saloni Sharma, Manisankar Ganguly, Nashrah Zaidi, Divyanshu Tiwari, Nabarun Roy, Nilanjana Banerjee, and Ramanuj Banerjee. Their work also involved collaboration with experts from the University of Tokyo, Japan—Fumiya Sano, Hiroaki Akasaka, Takaaki Kobayashi, Yuzuru Itoh, Wataru Shihoya, and Osamu Nureki—along with Andy Chevigne from the Luxembourg Institute of Health.
This study was funded by the DBT Wellcome Trust India Alliance, Science and Engineering Research Board (SERB), Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR), and LADY TATA Memorial Trust.
Building on this discovery, the IIT Kanpur team is now developing small molecules and antibodies aimed at targeting CXCR2. These therapeutics will undergo laboratory testing, followed by animal studies, bringing the team closer to offering innovative treatments for cancer and respiratory diseases. This achievement further underscores IIT Kanpur’s commitment to pioneering research that has the potential to revolutionize global healthcare and biomedical innovation.
-
Space & Physics6 months ago
Bubbles observed moving on a star for the first time
-
EDUNEWS & VIEWS4 months ago
India: Big Science in the 20th century and beyond
-
Interviews5 months ago
Memory Formation Unveiled: An Interview with Sajikumar Sreedharan
-
Space & Physics5 months ago
Nobel laureates in Physics recognized for contributions to Machine Learning
-
Society5 months ago
Global tech alliance: Nvidia partners with Reliance to transform AI landscape in India
-
The Sciences5 months ago
UFS researcher tackles plastic pollution with innovative biodegradable polymers
-
The Sciences5 months ago
Prof Saleem Badat awarded ASSAf Science-for-Society Gold Medal
-
Earth4 months ago
The wildfires, floods, and heatwaves: Understanding the science behind climate change