Connect with us

EDUNEWS & VIEWS

Will Canada remain a hub for Indian students amidst new restrictions?

New restrictions on student visas and work permits have sparked debate about the future of Canada as a preferred educational hub

Dipin Damodharan

Published

on

Image credit: Jose Jacob

As Canada continues to position itself as a leading destination for international students, recent policy changes are raising concerns about its appeal, particularly among Indian students. New restrictions on student visas and work permits have sparked debate about the future of Canada as a preferred educational hub.

In the past decade, Canada has seen a surge in international students, with Indian nationals being a significant contributor to this growth. According to recent statistics, Indian students constitute one of the largest groups of international students in Canada. India sent 225,000 students to Canada, a number that rose to 278,000 in 2023. For the first half of 2024, the count has reached 100,000 students. However, new regulations imposed by Canadian authorities aim to address issues of overstaying and unauthorized work, potentially impacting this vibrant demographic.

Policy Changes and Immediate Implications

The Canadian government’s recent policy changes include stricter requirements for student visas and modifications to work permit conditions. Under the new regulations, international students will face more rigorous checks before their applications are approved. Additionally, there are enhanced restrictions on the type and amount of work international students can undertake while studying.

The new rules mandate that students must now provide more detailed evidence of financial stability and academic intentions. Moreover, there will be an increase in the frequency of status reviews and a more stringent enforcement of existing work permit regulations. These measures are designed to curb the misuse of student visas and ensure that students adhere to their intended study programs.

For many Indian students, these changes represent a significant shift in their academic and professional plans. “The new restrictions have created a wave of uncertainty among students planning to study in Canada,” says Arjun Patel, a recent high school graduate who was preparing to enroll in a Canadian university. “We’re concerned about how these policies will affect our ability to work part-time and support ourselves while studying.”

Impact on Current and Prospective Students

For current international students in Canada, the immediate impact of these policy changes includes increased stress over visa renewals and job security. Many students who rely on part-time work to support their education and living expenses might find themselves restricted by the new regulations. This could lead to financial strain and affect their academic performance.

Jose Jacob, a Canadian immigrant, attributes the recent restrictions on international students in Canada to a combination of political and economic factors. “Education is a billion-dollar industry for Canada,” Jacob notes. “When I arrived here, and for many years since, community colleges have been major promoters of study abroad programs. Many of these institutions are private community colleges operating like businesses. More foreign students mean higher fees, which significantly boosts the industry.”

Jose Jacob

Jacob also points out that the Trudeau government has traditionally been supportive of immigration. Under Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, Canada has welcomed international students, offered residency, and invited refugees. “Trudeau’s policies are driven by the immigrant vote bank,” Jacob explains.

Prospective students face the challenge of navigating a more complex visa application process. The enhanced scrutiny may lead to longer processing times and additional paperwork, potentially causing delays in starting their studies. “The increased documentation requirements and the possibility of visa rejections have made the application process more daunting,” notes Rina Sharma, a prospective student from Delhi. “We’re concerned about how these changes will affect our plans and whether it will be worth the investment.”

Canada’s Commitment to International Education

Despite the new restrictions, Canadian officials have reiterated their commitment to international education. They emphasize that the changes are intended to preserve the integrity of the student visa system and ensure that students are genuinely pursuing their educational goals. The recent decision to impose restrictions on foreign students came amid significant domestic protests. “The decision was announced during a period of considerable political pressure,” Jose Jacob adds. He also highlights that the rising cost of living and housing shortages in places such as Ontario have contributed to the government’s decision. “The surge in housing prices and the increase in the cost of goods led to saturation,” he says.

“Canada remains dedicated to attracting top talent from around the world,” says, a spokesperson of a global education consulting group. “These policy adjustments are necessary to prevent abuse of the system and to ensure that our programs continue to benefit students who are committed to their studies.”

Moreover, educational institutions in Canada are working to support international students through these transitions. Many universities are enhancing their advisory services to help students navigate the new regulations and adjust their plans accordingly.

The Future of Canada as an Educational Destination

As Canada navigates these new policy changes, it faces the challenge of maintaining its status as a leading destination for international students. While the regulations are designed to address specific issues, they must balance the need for oversight with the desire to remain an attractive option for students worldwide.

For Indian students, the changing landscape presents both challenges and opportunities. While the new restrictions may complicate the immediate future, Canada’s robust educational infrastructure and diverse academic offerings continue to make it a compelling choice for many. The key will be how well the country can adapt to these changes while continuing to offer a supportive and enriching environment for international learners.

Image credit: Jose Jacob

Jacob suggests that these new regulations are also aimed at curbing fraudulent courses. “Previously, the U.S. was marketed to Europeans as the ‘Land of Opportunities,’ attracting early settlers. Similarly, Canada has been marketed as a land of opportunity for Indian students. Community colleges have collaborated with local educational consulting agencies to promote this image. However, the situation has become too saturated. Technical jobs are in higher demand now, and Canada remains a good option for students in those fields.”

Jacob also warns prospective students about the financial realities of living in Canada. “For those coming here to make money, it’s important to understand that it’s not like the Gulf countries. Taxes are very high—13 percent on everything,” he advises. “It’s crucial to be aware of these factors before making the move.”

To sum up, as Canada adjusts its policies regarding international students, it will be crucial for both the government and educational institutions to address the concerns of students and ensure that the country remains a welcoming and viable destination for those seeking higher education. The coming months will reveal whether Canada can sustain its reputation as a global education hub amidst these evolving regulations.

Dipin is Co-founder and Editor-in-Chief at EdPublica. A journalist and editor with over 15 years of experience leading and co-founding print and digital media outlets, his pieces on education, politics, and culture have been published in global media outlets, including The Huffington Post, The Himalayan Times, DailyO, Education Insider and so on.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

EDUNEWS & VIEWS

India is not in competition with any other nation: ISRO Chief

ISRO Chief V. Narayanan urges youth to lead India’s technological revolution

Published

on

ISRO Chairman V. Narayanan

In a powerful address at the 8th edition of the Chhatra Sansad India Conclave (CSI), ISRO (Indian Space Research Organisation) Chairman V. Narayanan inspired over 20,000 young minds to push boundaries and take India to new heights in space exploration and scientific innovation. His message was clear: the nation’s future in technology will be shaped by the youth, and they are crucial in propelling India to the forefront of global advancements.

In his keynote, V. Narayanan, Chairman of ISRO, spoke about India’s ongoing strides in space exploration. He emphasized that India is not in competition with any other nation but is focused solely on advancing its own technological progress. “India’s future is in the hands of its youth. You are the driving force behind the country’s technological and scientific transformation,” Narayanan said, calling for continued innovation in space research.

The conclave, held at Lovely Professional University, gathered influential leaders, policymakers, and thinkers under the theme “Vision India 2047: Bharat @ 100.” The event was a platform for dynamic conversations about India’s growth and the role youth will play in shaping the nation’s future as it approaches its centenary of independence.

Dr. Ashok Kumar Mittal, Member of Indian Parliament and Founder Chancellor of LPU, set the tone for the event, urging the youth to embrace their power to reshape India’s trajectory. He highlighted LPU’s commitment to nurturing future leaders who will lead the country in global arenas.

Dr. Ashok Kumar Mittal, Member of Parliament and Founder Chancellor of LPU giving memento to social reformerDr. Maulana Kalbe Rushaid Rizvi, during Chhatra Sansad India Conclave at LPU

Other prominent speakers at the conclave included Smriti Irani, former Union Minister, who encouraged the youth to leverage their talents to build businesses and enterprises that would drive India’s economic future. Motivational speaker Jaya Kishori inspired attendees to embody discipline, values, and purpose-driven action, while Temjen Imna Along, Minister of Tourism & Higher Education for Nagaland, spoke of an inclusive India where progress benefits all regions and communities.

The event also saw insightful video messages from several distinguished figures, including Nitin Gadkari, India’s Union Minister for Road Transport and Highways, and Vikrant Massey, Indian actor, emphasizing the role of youth in the ongoing digital revolution and India’s rise on the global stage.

A key feature of the conclave was a thought-provoking debate on “One Nation, One Election,” which sparked discussions on the potential impact of a unified electoral system on India’s future governance. The debate, chaired by Maulana Kalbe Rushaid Rizvi, allowed students to actively contribute their views on shaping India’s democratic structure.

Continue Reading

EDUNEWS & VIEWS

‘Blue Ghost’ soft-lands on the moon in one shape

With Blue Ghost’s successful soft-landing, Firefly Aerospace has become only the first private company ever to have a lunar probe intact on the lunar surface.

Published

on

The Blue Ghost's shadow looms over the foreground in the image | Credit: NASA/Firefly Aerospace

On March 2, NASA confirmed the first ever successful soft-landing attempt by a private company. Firefly Aerospace’s lunar lander, the Blue Ghost Mission 1 (named after a rare species of fireflies thought native to the United States), touched down at precisely 2.04 p.m. IST, near Mons Latrielle at Mare Crisium on the moon’s near side. Firefly Aerospace issued a press release shortly thereafter.

The soft-landing comes after another US-based private company, Intuitive Machines, attempted one a year ago. On that occasion however, the lander, known as Odyssey, bounced off hard on the lunar surface at touchdown, following a steep descent. It rested titled with a stray lunar rock to offer a shoulder. In contrast, Blue Ghost which stuck both an upright landing, and its payloads intact.

The landing was the culmination of a 45 day trip that began early this year. On January 15, Blue Ghost blasted to space aboard a SpaceX’s Falcon 9 Block 5 from NASA’s Kennedy Space Centre, Florida. Sharing space during the launch was yet another commercial lunar lander, the Hakuto-R Mission 2  – built and operated by the Japanese space technology company, ispace. However, Hakuto-R has a projected landing date on the moon sometime in April, owing to a different arrival approach.

Firefly had released pictures of the lunar terrain, the Blue Ghost‘s photographed from its landing site. One of them shows a rugged gray dusty terrain, with a portion of the lander’s chassis in view in the foreground. Whereas a second one showed a desolate terrain with the earth reflecting sunlight above the horizon. Blue Ghost‘s shadow looms in the foreground in the image.

This site located close to Mons Latrielle, is what scientists think is an ancient basin formed upon a rogue asteroid impact eons ago. More than 500 km wide, Mare Crisium, as the basin is known by, is believed to have been flooded by lava in volcanic eruptions dating to some 4 billion years ago.

The SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket that carried Firefly Aerospace’s lunar lander, Blue Ghost Mission 1, is seen stationed here at NASA’s Kennedy Space Center, Florida | Credit: NASA

Laying groundwork for NASA’s Artemis

“Firefly is literally and figuratively over the Moon,” Jason Kim, CEO of Firefly Aerospace, said shortly after the landing, in a press release.  “Our Blue Ghost lunar lander now has a permanent home on the lunar surface with 10 NASA payloads and a plaque with every Firefly employee’s name. This bold, unstoppable team has proven we’re well equipped to deliver reliable, affordable access to the Moon, and we won’t stop there. With annual lunar missions, Firefly is paving the way for a lasting lunar presence that will help unlock access to the rest of the solar system for our nations, our partners, and the world.”

In 2023, Firefly Aerospace ferried the instruments as part of a $93.3 million contract signed with NASA as part of the Commercial Lunar Payload Services (CLPS) program. The CLPS program is Nasa’s attempt at driving private participation on future lunar missions. But the payloads help set stage for NASA’s Artemis program, which would mark their first attempt since the Apollo program, to land astronauts on the lunar surface.

Some of the payloads reflect the new engineering demands for such long-term lunar missions. To streamline tracking lander and rovers on the moon, NASA supplied the Lunar GNSS Receiver Experiment (LuGRE). It is a GNSS receiver to help earth-orbiting satellite constellations, including GPS and the Galileo, track the lunar lander with high accuracy in real-time. Another one is the Regolith Adherence Characterization (RAC) that investigates possible soil degradation left behind in the wake of a typical lunar mission soft-landing.

Other payloads were designed to explore various science objectives. Research institutes and universities across the United States contributed to a variety of instruments. They included laser retro reflectors to measure distances, an x-ray imaging device to study how the solar wind affects space weather on earth; a probe which can inject itself into the moon’s sub-surface to measure heat dissipation.

In a press release applauding Blue Ghost’s successful soft-landing attempt, NASA’s acting administrator, Janet Petro, said, “This incredible achievement demonstrates how Nasa and American companies are leading the way in space exploration for the benefit of all … We have already learned many lessons – and the technological and science demonstrations onboard Firefly’s Blue Ghost Mission 1 will improve our ability to not only discover more science, but to ensure the safety of our spacecraft instruments for future human exploration – both in the short term and long term.”

Continue Reading

EDUNEWS & VIEWS

Indian kids use different math skills at work vs. school

The research, which involved over 200 children, compared the performances of children engaged in market work with those focused solely on their studies

Published

on

Image by Rajesh Balouria from Pixabay

A recent study conducted in Delhi sheds light on the contrasting mathematical abilities of children who work in markets versus those who attend school, raising questions about how educational systems can better address these disparities. The research, which involved over 200 children, compared the performances of children engaged in market work with those focused solely on their studies.

In the study, children were tasked with solving math problems under various conditions. Remarkably, 85 percent of children with market jobs were able to answer a complex market transaction problem correctly, while only 10 percent of their school-going counterparts succeeded in solving a similar question. However, when the same group was given simple division and subtraction problems, with pencil and paper for assistance, the results shifted. Fifty-nine percent of school kids solved the problems correctly, while only 45 percent of market-working children did.

The researchers also introduced a word problem involving a boy buying vegetables at the market. One-third of market-working children successfully solved the problem without any aid, whereas fewer than 1 percent of schoolchildren were able to do the same. This stark difference in performance highlights the potential benefits that practical, real-world experience in the marketplace can offer.

Why, then, do nonworking students seem to struggle more under market conditions?

“They learned an algorithm but didn’t understand it,” said researcher Abhijit Banerjee, explaining the phenomenon. On the other hand, market-working children appeared to have developed useful strategies for managing transactions. One notable example was their use of rounding to simplify calculations. For instance, when faced with multiplying 43 by 11, many market kids would round 43 to 40, multiply by 10, and then add 43 to get the correct result of 473—an intuitive trick that seemed to help them tackle problems more efficiently.

“The market kids are able to exploit base 10, so they do better on base 10 problems,” said Esther Duflo, co-author of the study. “The school kids have no idea. It makes no difference to them.” Conversely, the schoolchildren demonstrated a better understanding of formal written methods for division and subtraction.

The findings raise an important issue: while market-working children excel in solving real-world problems quickly, they may be missing out on the formal education necessary for long-term academic success. “It would likely be better for the long-term futures if they also did well in school and wound up with a high school degree or better,” Banerjee said.

The divide between the intuitive problem-solving skills of market kids and the formal methods taught in school suggests that a new approach could be beneficial in the classroom. Banerjee suspects that traditional teaching methods, which often prioritize a single, formal approach to solving problems, may be limiting. He advocates for encouraging students to reason their way toward an approximation of the correct answer, a method that aligns more closely with the informal strategies used by market-working children.

Despite these concerns, Duflo emphasized, “We don’t want to blame the teachers. It’s not their fault. They are given a strict curriculum to follow, and strict methods to follow.”

The question remains: how can schools adjust their teaching methods to better support students’ diverse problem-solving strategies? The research team is actively exploring new experiments to address this issue, with the goal of creating a more inclusive and effective educational system.

“These findings highlight the importance of educational curricula that bridge the gap between intuitive and formal mathematics,” the authors concluded.

The study was supported by the Abdul Latif Jameel Poverty Action Lab’s Post-Primary Education Initiative, the Foundation Blaise Pascal, and the AXA Research Fund.

Continue Reading

Trending